Originally Posted by
smootness
Maybin at this point pretty much is what he is. May happen to strike it hot and OPS about .700 here and there, but more likely to be a guy with an OBP right around .300 with little power.
He and EY Jr. are pretty comparable, honestly. I mean, Maybin has basically the same WAR as BJ over the last 2 years if that tells you anything.
Looking at 2011 is like Padres fans getting excited over the possibility of BJ hitting like he did in Tampa.
28 isn't old, but it's definitely past 'could still reach his potential' level. At 28, you are what you are.