So many people vastly overrating Maybin's value... hint, with his contract, there was very little. They did try and trade him at the deadline... no takers.
Last edited by zbhargrove; 11-21-2015 at 07:15 AM.
50PoundHead (11-21-2015), clvclv (11-21-2015)
Yup. He was being paid almost exactly what his projected production is worth on the FA market. Meaning very little surplus value which is what drives a player's trade value. But I think JC was implying in an interview earlier this week that there were several teams wanting him at the trade deadline and the fact that the club didn't trade him there was some sort of proof that they were not tanking. Well that's a completely different issue and has to be viewed as the sort of clumsy spinning that is rapidly becoming one of JC's trademarks.
Last edited by nsacpi; 11-21-2015 at 08:21 AM.
Braves1976 (03-20-2016), jpx7 (11-21-2015)
Braves1976 (03-20-2016), bravesnumberone (11-21-2015), jpx7 (11-21-2015), nsacpi (11-21-2015), Runnin (11-21-2015)
My first reaction is kinda meh, but this smells like a precursor trade.
BedellBrave (11-21-2015), clvclv (11-21-2015), DirkPiggler (11-21-2015)
Has there EVER been a statement and question a certain someone should absolutely never have made and asked publicly more than...
Kinda pathetic to see yourself as a message board knight in shining armor. How impotent does someone have to be in real life to resort to playing hero on a message board?
GovClintonTyree (11-21-2015)
FreemanFan (11-24-2015), jpx7 (11-21-2015), Julio3000 (11-21-2015), Runnin (11-21-2015)
I kind of chuckle. I don't know if anyone is being inconsistent, but when we obtained Maybin there was no robust "Oh! Look who we just traded for!" When he had a solid first half the chorus from many was "Just wait!" We don't move him at the deadline and while some thought he should have been moved, the return would have likely been very similar to what we received now. I like Maybin's tools, but he just hasn't been able to apply them consistently. I thought Seitzer had solved him, but then he took a nosedive. He's really a highly-paid 4th OF.
zbhargrove (11-21-2015)
I know this was answered already, but I wanted to expand on it a little bit. Aybar doesn't significantly improve the offense. Sure, he's an upgrade on Tron, but likely only a marginal one. He could surprise us, but I think it's unlikely. So we got more pitching prospects. Those prospects give us depth to trade from to acquire offense. That's fine, but until it happens it's purely speculative, so I suspect it's going to be an active topic of conversation.
As for the Maybin trade, I understand it. It makes sense to move his salary, and I understand that we can only expect so much in return. Still, I liked Cam and thought he was a good guy to have around. His positive attitude and hustle seemed like a good thing to have in the dugout and clubhouse.
Personally, it's another tough moment in this stretch for me--guys I like and have developed a rooting interest in getting a ticket out of town: JHey, Tron, Cam, Kelly...and Julio may be next. Tough times.
To be honest, I've probably been Cam's biggest supporter since before he was traded for AND when everyone wanted to trade him. The main thing the trade signals (to me) is that the brass seems to be pretty confident that Mallex is going to be capable of producing at (at least) the same level as Maybin or Bourn at a pretty early point this season. I'd buy (and several times made) the argument that Cam's highest value was to us - he:
1.) is better than Bourn for the "win now" crowd
2.) saved the team money in the long run with nothing other than his presence by keeping Bourn's option from vesting
3.) had the "perfect" contract - as nsacpi points out, he was making about what he's worth - and that contract wouldn't get in the way of promoting Smith at any point. You were going to be able to get SOMETHING for him when you decided it was Mallex' time, even if it wasn't something "great" (which certainly seems to be the case here) or you decided to allocate his money elsewhere.
There were a whole lot of people (here in particular) who loved to point out that Cameron wasn't much of a player - many hated his defense (and it wasn't as good as it had been in the past), and consistently pointed out that he wasn't "the answer" with his 0.6 WAR. His bat showed more signs of improvement than Andrelton's, even if that wasn't enough to make him a consistent threat to help the offense much. He's a high-energy, sometimes exciting player who gives his all every day and absolutely loved being here.
In the end, he is what he is. Without being in the middle of a hot streak and with other free-agent options available to everyone else, we probably got about what you'd hope to get for him - a couple of lottery tickets. You save some money that you CAN spend elsewhere. It remains to be seen where that money will be spent. The Tigers traded for one year of the right-handed half of a platoon at slightly below market value. If the trade were reversed and we gave up two under-25 LHPs for that, many people here would be just as upset.
Has there EVER been a statement and question a certain someone should absolutely never have made and asked publicly more than...
Kinda pathetic to see yourself as a message board knight in shining armor. How impotent does someone have to be in real life to resort to playing hero on a message board?
BoneThrower (11-21-2015)
Wait, there's a "win now" crowd?
Exactly my take on it. I loved having him here - local kid (his Uncle's an acquaintance of mine) who's a really good guy. I still have his Tigers jersey hanging in my mancave (haven't gotten his Braves jersey yet, but still plan to order one to hang beside it). Really hate seeing him go from a personal standpoint, but I get it. I just hope it works out.
Has there EVER been a statement and question a certain someone should absolutely never have made and asked publicly more than...
Kinda pathetic to see yourself as a message board knight in shining armor. How impotent does someone have to be in real life to resort to playing hero on a message board?
I'm fine with the trade. He's not that good and we will suck nxt yr
I do not get the surplus of comments. Bourn and swisher are not players. They are Chris Johnson's salary moved to this yr so it will be gone in magical 17. The can't play bc they suck and bc of their vesting clauses. If u had a surplus of problem just cut them.
Plus the other of bat is bc they gave away a stud pitcher under control and a good prospect for an ok over 40 bat without a position
The only way I see this cost savings helping us is if we take on someone else's Melvin upton contract in exchange for a b prospect or better bat