REAL FOOTBALL Thread

[BRule]

Julio has missed games or playing time every year. he already was scratched from the first preseason game.

Games played last year

Julio - 16 games
White - 16 games
Nelson - 12 games

*Side note, Roddy has never missed a game in his career*

[zitothebrave]

Please name 5-7 better.

You can argue a few in there.

Falcons, Broncos, Giants, Packers, Saints.

I would put them in the 3-5 range personally.

[Heyward]

Please name 5-7 better.

Niners.
Broncos.
Falcons.
Packers.
Giants.
Saints.

[zitothebrave]

Games played last year

Julio - 16 games
White - 16 games
Nelson - 12 games

*Side note, Roddy has never missed a game in his career*

Convenient you left out 2011 when Julio missed 3 games. Julio also only played like 2 snaps in the Carolina game before straining something. But I shouldn't have expected you to know that.

[gilesfan]

You can argue a few in there.

Falcons, Broncos, Giants, Packers, Saints.

I would put them in the 3-5 range personally.

Giants are at least debatable. Packers/Saints-gtfo.

Saints now have Colston/Moore/Graham and who?

And neither Colston or Moore are anywhere close to Dez.

[BRule]

Convenient you left out 2011 when Julio missed 3 games. Julio also only played like 2 snaps in the Carolina game before straining something. But I shouldn't have expected you to know that.

As YOU said, we are talking about LAST year.

[zitothebrave]

Giants are at least debatable. Packers/Saints-gtfo.

Saints now have Colston/Moore/Graham and who?

And neither Colston or Moore are anywhere close to Dez.

Colston more and Graham is a heck of a start.

And if your argument is that no one is close to as almost as the number 1 receiver than the Lions receiving Corps>All. Heck by that definition the Cardinals should be in the top 5 mix.

[zitothebrave]

As YOU said, we are talking about LAST year.

No I didn't. But you can continue to imagine that.

[yeezus]

Niners.
Broncos.
Falcons.
Packers.
Giants.
Saints.

I really disagree.
No way I take the Niners, Packers, or Saints.
Dez might be the best WR on any of those teams.

[Heyward]

Giants are at least debatable. Packers/Saints-gtfo.

Saints now have Colston/Moore/Graham and who?

And neither Colston or Moore are anywhere close to Dez.

Are you arguing WR/TE as a whole or the top 3-4?

And Colston is criminally underrated.

[Heyward]

I really disagree.
No way I take the Niners, Packers, or Saints.
Dez might be the best WR on any of those teams.

I'd take Julio and Thomas over Dez.

[gilesfan]

Convenient you left out 2011 when Julio missed 3 games. Julio also only played like 2 snaps in the Carolina game before straining something. But I shouldn't have expected you to know that.

In 2012?

[gilesfan]

Are you arguing WR/TE as a whole or the top 3-4?

And Colston is criminally underrated.

As a whole, but really not much weight should be put on 4/5/6 WR.

Colston is good, he aint Dez Bryant though.

Niners, Packers, Saints, WTF do you get this stuff from?

[yeezus]

I'd take Julio and Thomas over Dez.

Julio is debatable.
Thomas looked a lot better with Peyton. Dez would set records on that team.

[Heyward]

Julio is debatable.
Thomas looked a lot better with Peyton. Dez would set records on that team.

Thomas had the second most yards in the NFL in December with Tebow as QB a few years ago, dumb argument. Only behind Calvin.

[Heyward]

As a whole, but really not much weight should be put on 4/5/6 WR.

Colston is good, he aint Dez Bryant though.

Niners, Packers, Saints, WTF do you get this stuff from?

Crabtree, Boldin, Manningham, and VD is pretty good as a unit.

[yeezus]

Thomas had the second most yards in the NFL in December with Tebow as QB a few years ago, dumb argument. Only behind Calvin.

So for one month he had the 2nd most yards and that means Peyton didn't make him look a whole lot better?
Uhh ok.. That's cherry-picking epitomized.

[gilesfan]

Crabtree, Boldin, Manningham, and VD is pretty good as a unit.

Its isn't close to some of the others listed.

[gilesfan]

So for one month he had the 2nd most yards and that means Peyton didn't make him look a whole lot better?
Uhh ok.. That's cherry-picking epitomized.

D. Thomas is a stud, imo. He started slow, which occasionally happens with WR prospects. (especially from triple option offense in college) Then he had Tebow at QB.

I would put him top 10 for sure. Prolly higher.

[yeezus]

D. Thomas is a stud, imo. He started slow, which occasionally happens with WR prospects. (especially from triple option offense in college) Then he had Tebow at QB.

I would put him top 10 for sure. Prolly higher.

Not saying he isn't really good. I just think Dez is better.