I don't think we'll get Sale, but I think we'll get a controllable starter to team with Julio and Folty. We probably have certain players we deem expendable and making the rounds to see who will say Yes.
I'd actually want Quintana over Sale.
That would just be so shortsighted, IMO. We would lose as much as about 5-6 WAR on this year's team because Mallex and Jace aren't replacing much of the value of Albies and Inciarte. So even if Sale continues to be awesome, that's not much of a net gain, and you lose all of Albies' and Newcombs' futures.
I'm typically one who comes up with all these hopeful deals that he hates, but unless Chicago will take far less than I think they would I hope this is just "Hot Stove talk" as well. Heyman pointing out that we have the pieces to get it done really isn't significant IMO. Everyone around the game knows we have the pieces to get it done.
I'm afraid I agree with thewupk - I'm not sure we're close enough to sell out for that "last piece" just yet. If we could get an "Ace" for ONE of our premium arms and another piece or two not named Albies or Maitan, sure I'd do it. I'm just not including multiple premium arms (Newcomb/Fried/Toussaint/Allard/Soroka/Anderson/Wentz/Muller) and core pieces like Inciarte or Albies to get it done because doing so takes away pieces we'd need to win now even if we added an "Ace'.
Has there EVER been a statement and question a certain someone should absolutely never have made and asked publicly more than...
Kinda pathetic to see yourself as a message board knight in shining armor. How impotent does someone have to be in real life to resort to playing hero on a message board?
smootness (11-15-2016)
I think you're going to have to give up something premium. He's Chris Sale. If you believe Smith is a reasonable replacement for Inciarte - and as good as Ender is, he's not irreplaceable - and you think you've got other options at 2B (and I do) - then I think you have to strongly consider this deal.
There was a lot of anticipation for our pitchers coming up in 2016. How did that work out?
I DO consider multiple premium arms and players, if I think Chris Sale puts us in the hunt. And while I understand it might be better if we were a year further along, I still make a deal if I can live with it (and obviously, I'm more inclined to part with good stuff than you are, which is cool).
Yeah, I'm not saying it's an unfair deal, I'm just saying it wouldn't make a lot of sense for us. I just don't think we're close enough to say, 'Alright, get an ace to put us over the top,' and doing so destroys a good chunk of the rebuild and worsens your long-term outlook.
These are the main points - to me - that would keep me from pulling the trigger.
I'm pretty high on Mallex compared to some, but he's a substantial downgrade from Inciarte. No, Albies isn't here "yet", but Jace is a considerable downgrade from him as well. Your point about the anticipation and expectations for guys like Wisler and Blair and the fact that they fell short should (again JMO) make the brass even more hesitant to go "all-in" just yet.
Again, I'm far from unwilling to part with serious talent. If something like Newcomb/Wisler or Blair/Mallex/Demeritte or Riley gets it done, I wouldn't bat an eye. I'm just not willing to back the truck up for for 3 years of Chris Sale when we don't have "sure things" that will produce at 2B, 3B, and behind the plate. If that package isn't enough for Sale, tell them they can have it for Quintana or offer a little different version of it to Tampa Bay for Archer.
I'm just not sold enough on Sale with all his question marks - size, durability, and makeup after his blow up last summer - to mortgage the future for him when we still have as many question marks as we do.
Has there EVER been a statement and question a certain someone should absolutely never have made and asked publicly more than...
Kinda pathetic to see yourself as a message board knight in shining armor. How impotent does someone have to be in real life to resort to playing hero on a message board?