LOL Gattis is a fine defensive C.
If we have to deal him I understand. He's more valuable at DH.
I wouldn't deal Gattis.
I would trade Upton, don't know if I'd include Minor though. His value has never been lower. I would trade some other options but I don't think we'll get fair return for MM.
What I would try to do is Upton and Bethancourt for someone. I know it will upset some but I don't think Bethancourt will ever hit enough.
Stockholm, more densely populated than NYC - sturg
tomahawkchop10 (08-26-2014)
Board's thoughts on:
BJ Upton
Mike Minor
for
Tim Lincecum
no money changing hands.
Would we do it? Would SF do it?
Well, it's basically trading Minor for $23M, and a hope and a prayer that Roger could made Lincecum relevant again
The biggest issue with this team is a brutal offense. I don't see any reason to trade one of our better bats in Gattis.
ESP47 (08-27-2014)
What good is it for DOB to write that Upton will be moved while he's still here? I see this ending badly.
I'm no B. Upton fan, but I'd have waited till the offseason to say this out loud.
tomahawkchop10 (08-26-2014), zedsdead (08-27-2014)
You can tell it's a **** season when DOB is writing an offseason blog in August.
zedsdead (08-27-2014)
I don't wanna get rid of Gattis either but if it meant getting rid of BJ I would.
No way that I'd dump BJ until I had resigned Justin. I'm sure Justin understands the business of baseball, etc, but I bet we'd save more resigning Justin with BJ still having a chance to play here than we would save in a BJ dump trade. That's and hoping BJ gets a Lasik, etc miracle this winter are really our only ways to minimizes our losses on this horrible contract. Or maybe BJ will get desperate and get on a good PED program!