I'm really not sure what you're trying to argue.
Justin Upton hit 29 HR last year and was one of the top hitters in the league. Gattis hit 22 bombs in 400 PAs. Jason . . . yeah, Jason quit hitting HRs, but he also had a career low (full season) year for strikeouts. Those are the guys you're talking about, right? Those are the guys at issue, and the ones you're taking veiled (or not so veiled) shots at. What's wrong with that production and why wouldn't you want it in the lineup this year?