Originally Posted by
TheBravos
I really don't get the point of this. You don't buy a rooster for eggs. It's like having a deep discussion on where Inciarte ranks as a homerun hitter.
We know Inciarte is a great defensive player with limited power. We know Kemp is a average at best defender, but can mash the ball.
Sure, there are a few outfielders that hit for power, average and are excellent defenders....we will not be able to afford one unless he's home grown because they are RARE. We couldn't afford Jhey who would be in that category and his hitting comes and goes.
You don't need all quick guys that can cover an acre in 2 seconds and you don't need all big slow power guys (note 80% fall in one category or another). Kemp is what he is, just like Inciarte is what he is.
Kemp was brought in to hit....he's doing better than expected. I never hoped for him to be a stellar defensive guy (that's a pipe dream). He has done better than expected in the field also. Win/Win.