Who you got? Apparently Albies is currently not a prospect, but I'm curious where folks would rank him if he was still a prospect, so for the purpose of this thread assume that he's still a prospect:
1) Albies
2) Acuna
3) Gohara
4) Soroka
5) Allard
6) Wright
7) Anderson
8) Waters
9) Fried
10) Minter
thank you weso1!
nsacpi (01-23-2018)
1.Acuna
2.Albies
3.Gohara
4.Wright
5.Soroka
6.Anderson
7.Allard
8.Riley
9.Fried
10.Pache
11.Wilson
12.Touki
13.Wentz
14.Conteras
15.Waters
1) Acuna
.
.
.
2.) Albies
3) Gohara
4) Soroka
5) Allard
6) Wright
7) Anderson
8) Pache
9) Fried
10) Riley
Albies still considered a prospect?
OP said for this thread Oz is a prospect to see how he ranks.Originally Posted by TheBravos
Coppy
Top 10 mlb prospects...
1. Albies
2. Acuna
3. Wentz
4. Anderson
5. Soroka
6. Riley
7. Allard
8. Pache
9. Wilson
10. Vlad jr
thethe and I worked on this and put in a ton of research
Got to set up a new thread as a deflection from the childish rant. Transparent strategy.
....
1. Acuna.
2. Gohara.
3. Soroka.
4. Wright.
5. Allard.
6. Anderson.
7. Pache.
8. Wentz.
9. Wilson.
10. Riley.
I would actually put Albies above Acuna if he were still rookie eligible.
"I am a victim, I will tell you. I am a victim."
"I am your retribution."
Acuna
Gohara
Wright
Soroka
Allard
Riley
Anderson
Fried
Wentz
Pache
1) Acuna
2) Albies
3) Gohara
4) Wright
5) Anderson
6) Soroka
7) Allard
8) Fried
9) Riley
10) Toussaint
11) Pache
Wilson, Wentz, Contreras, Waters are all in the discussion for me. Excited to see JCE and Ramos this year to see if they can shoot up the list.
Last edited by mqt; 01-23-2018 at 08:55 AM.
Acuna
Albies
Gohara
Wright
Soroka
Anderson
Allard
Riley
Fried
Toussaint
Acuna is still #1 because his hitting profile is insane but Albies makes up a lot of ground in that race for being a plus defender up the middle. That value carries a lot of weight.
Ventura's Stolen Bases
For me (never watched anyone other than in majors when internet worked)
Acuña
Albies
Gohara
Soroka
Wright
Anderson
Fried
Allard
Wentz
Riley
Honorable mention: Cash considerations
Julio3000 (01-23-2018), UNCBlue012 (01-23-2018)
If Albies were still considered a prospect, it would be close between him and Acuna. I guess I would lean slightly in favor of Acuna.
1. Acuna
2. Albies
3. Gohara
4. Soroka
5. Wright
6. Anderson
7. Allard
8. Pache
9. Riley
10. Wentz
Something I'm really interested to see is if Weigel can bounce back and become something of interest. He is a dark horse to be in Atlanta's top 10 by the end of the season
Ventura's Stolen Bases
I don’t think Weigel is expected back for real until like 2019 (as far as making an impact), unfortunately. He looked good before his injury though.
1) Acuna
2) Albies
3) Gohara
4) Wright
5) Anderson
6) Soroka
7) Allard
8) Fried
9) Riley
10) Pache
11) Davidson
No way Davidson is even close to Wentz or Touki. He probably isn’t a top 20 prospect in the system at this point.
I don't think he is above Wentz or Touki, but Davidson has been getting a good bit of love from some of the scouting community. He might be a top 15 prospect at this point, and I definitely think he is in the top 20.
All subjective. He's my darkhorse.
The actual order if Albies is included goes:
1. Acuna (FV 65+ nearly MLB ready)
2. Albies (FV 60 position prospect already at the MLB level)
3. Gohara (FV 60 pitching prospect already at the MLB level)
4. Wright
5. Soroka (FV 55 top performer)
6. Allard (I still believe!)
7. Anderson (FV 55 at lowest level)
8. Pache (FV 50 position prospect with highest floor)
9. Riley (borderline FV 50 position prospect over the MLB swingman)
10. Fried (LHed swingmen out of the BP are valuable)
11. Wentz (since Albies isn't actually eligible)
HM. Minter (FV 45 MLB ready BP arm)
/thread
Last edited by Enscheff; 01-23-2018 at 12:13 PM.
I think the desire to include albies speaks to a better measure of organizational health than prospect ratings....talent under 25.
The Braves should start to have a bright future with talent under 25 contributing at the MLB level.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote