You guys do realize that other teams have taken the Cubs' approach in the past of targeting position players and failed?
Theo has done an excellent job in Chicago, but he's been very, very, very fortunate that so many have worked out. Any team building strategy is a good one if your success rate is a 100%.
The Rays top prospect (Willy Adames) was acquired for David Price. They also acquired Daniel Robertson (3rd ranked prospect) for Ben Zobrist. THe number 2 prospect (Souza) was acquired for a bat. 7 of their top 10 prospects are position players. I think you could argue they've made a clear shift to trying to load up on position players.
"Yes, I did think Aldrich was good UNTIL I SAW HIM PLAY. "- thethe
Drury and Ahmed were the very definition of throw in pieces (at the time at least).
It's seems rather petty to criticize the team for picking the wrong players when the players they did get are almost universally performing well with the only exception being Rio Ruiz (the young offensive player we got fwiw).
Hey guys, I don't post here that much but am a loyal lurker. Anyways, appreciate your guys' insight on the draft...couple of questions:
1) Where does a guy like Allard slot into our prospect rankings off the bat?
2) How are teams' money pools determined? How do the Astros end up with $17M?
3) Don't teams receive a compensatory pick if a player they draft doesn't sign? What would the risk have been had the Braves nabbed Daz at 28 but not signed him? (Aside from opportunity cost of drafting a signable player like Soroka)
Otis Nixon? Come on dude, you are better than that.
2 of the largest parts (and maybe the 2 most highly coveted players) in the Tex trade were Salty and Andrus
Grissom was traded for Tarasco, Kelly, and Yan. To use that as support is really odd since Tarasco was the most highly thought of player in the deal.
I'm not going to argue the Braves have never used a pitcher to acquire a hitter, but your examples are terrible.
"Yes, I did think Aldrich was good UNTIL I SAW HIM PLAY. "- thethe
1) I'd say somewhere in the top 10 but not easy to break the top 5 right now.
2) Each pick is assigned a monetary value and the aggregate determines your pool. Astros have more becuase they failed to sign Aiken last year and get that pick back mean more money.
3) Answered in (2). Yes, you get that pick back the following year. Not sure how the order is determined though.
Natural Immunity Croc
1) Kiley McDaniel pegged him as a 55-60 FV if healthy. That would put him as likely our second or third best prospect behind Ozzie Albies.
2) The bonus pools are determined as a summation of the allocated slot for each draft pick. The more picks you have, then the more money you get.
3) Draft picks are protected up to 2 years. So if a player doesn't sign then you get a pick the next year. If a player doesn't sign the next year with the compensation pick then you get one more pick the next year before it vanishes.
Lots of Georgia high school kids still on the board: RHP Dakota Chalmers, LHH OF Chad Smith, IF/OF Alonzo Jones, Cs Joey Bart and Christopher Cullen, SS Jalen Miller. A ton of other pitchers.
IF Trey Cabbage is a highly-ranked HS hitter out of Grainger, Tennessee. He's played his summer ball for an East Cobb team (Team Elite Roadrunners), so the Braves have probably had a very good look at him.
Curious if the Braves mine the JCs in the SE today at all. A few guys out of Chipola (FL) JC: LHP Mac Marshall, OF/1B Isiah Gilliam, and OF Reese Cooley. Wallace-Hanceville RHP Chad Smith (not to be confused with Snellville, GA, HS OF Chad Smith) is another guy. Two guys out of Shelton State (AL) CC: Gargantuan LHP Chase Johnson-Mullins and RHP Grayson Jones. RHP Scooter Hightower out of Columbia (TN) JC.
jpx7 (06-09-2015)
I don't want us to narrow our focus on anything in specific. If the strategy is always take BPA, then I think that applies to prospect accumulation as well.
For as much love as the Cubs have gotten in this thread, they just spent 150 million on a 32 year old starting pitcher.
thethe (06-09-2015)