The last time Arcia played SS with any regularity was 2020, and he was roughly average defensively. To be honest, his 2022 season was nearly identical in value to both his offensive and defensive output. If he can manage that production over 140-150 games at SS, that would make him a 1.5 - 2 win player. Do we really expect Grissom/Shewmake to be better than that?

As much I would rather give the young guys a shot, Arcia is probably the better choice
I would just rather have a better reserve player than Adrianza.