This is the type of short sighted view I expect Dino-Snit takes. Yes, he takes a 1 game hit in performance at 1 spot in the order, and if the dozen braincells he is rubbing together can only comprehend that much of the world, then sitting a guy 1 extra day per month is nothing but a negative.
However, allowing a few more braincells into the mix lets you realize you gain:
- A more rested star who is less likely to get injured in a fatigue related play, usually soft tissue injuries. This is quite literally what load management is.
- A bench player who gets 3-4 starts per month who is now more ready to step in if needed, rather than needed a ST period for 1-2 weeks to ramp up.
- A selling point to future bench players that this team doesn't let guys rot away for months on end.
- A platoon advantage in the games you selectively allow these bench players to play. Grichuk vs a LHP isn't such a huge downgrade, for example.
So yeah, I would think the benefits of letting the primary bench IFer get 3-4 starts a month at the expense of 1 start per month from Riley/Arcia/Albies/Olson is probably a worthwhile trade to get all those listed benefits.