GDT 4/24/24: Braves vs Marlins - Lopez is our Tromp card

[thewupk]

Not that this needs to be said but Bonds never pitched.

I just don't see an argument that Ohtani isn't the single greatest baseball player ever.

Because 3 years doesn't mean ****. Ohtani has 26.1 fWAR the last 3 seasons.

Bonds has multiple 3 year stretches that eclipse that.

[thethe]

Because 3 years doesn't mean ****. Ohtani has 26.1 fWAR the last 3 seasons.

Bonds has multiple 3 year stretches that eclipse that.

Its a fair argument then - Ohtani hasn't been able to stay on the field.

I just look at it that the difference between Bonds hitting ability and Ohtanis doesn't make up for hte fact that Bonds couldn't pitch and Ohtani is a top 20 starter currently.

[zbhargrove]

Its a fair argument then - Ohtani hasn't been able to stay on the field.

I just look at it that the difference between Bonds hitting ability and Ohtanis doesn't make up for hte fact that Bonds couldn't pitch and Ohtani is a top 20 starter currently.

How in the world can you call someone a top 20 starter who is currently recovering from TJS?

[thewupk]

Its a fair argument then - Ohtani hasn't been able to stay on the field.

I just look at it that the difference between Bonds hitting ability and Ohtanis doesn't make up for hte fact that Bonds couldn't pitch and Ohtani is a top 20 starter currently.

Except when you look at WAR Bonds more than makes up for it. At multiple points in his career.