Actually, if we want to post facts, he got injured April 29th running into the wall and jacking up his hip and bruised ribs. He didn't learn and injured his knee running into the wall on May 13th. It wasn't till May 25th when sliding into 2nd and hobbling around (on the 26th) that they decided that they've run their injured phenom into the ground enough to shut him down.Originally Posted by Carp
"Yes, I did think Aldrich was good UNTIL I SAW HIM PLAY. "- thethe
Rizzo is one of the best GM's in baseball, but they have really had their fair share of bozo managers that have tried their damnedest to mess that situation up.
Thank you for the clarification.
I think its clear that when Harper is healthy he is dominant. As long as he is healthy I believe he will be the best hitter in baseball and so far he is showing that and its not particularly close.
Natural Immunity Croc
Yeah, Rizzo is excellent scout/talent guy. Its odd they treated Stras with gloves and yet Harper play demolition derby with his body.
"Yes, I did think Aldrich was good UNTIL I SAW HIM PLAY. "- thethe
Heyward benched again today vs a lefty (Also happens to be Niese, the one who smashed his face). Wonder if this platoon thing is real.
9 games actually and about 33 PA's. Which accounted for about 1/4 of all the PA's he had up to that point in the season.
Of course it's SSS. Just like his April was a SSS. 100 at bats isn't enough of a sample to judge anything, other than someone is playing very well.
Last edited by Carp; 05-19-2015 at 03:59 PM.
The knee injury which kept him out most of the season happened on May 13.
His age is irrelevant. You were the one calling him the best hitter in baseball when he was 20 years old. And you were wrong.
Last edited by Carp; 05-19-2015 at 04:00 PM.
Injuries will sap even the best players. The facts are the facts. When Harper is healthy he performs like the best hitter in baseball.
Natural Immunity Croc
Projections are not facts. If you aren't projecting then what you are saying is categorically false because the last month is the only time in his whole career has ever performed as the best hitter in baseball.
If you weren't so obtuse about this you might actually get some traction, but speaking in absolutes has, once again, put you in a corner where the only way out is to make even more outrageous claims.
Only sith deal in absolutes
thethe must be a sith
The Chosen One (05-19-2015)
When besides this year has he performed like the best hitter in baseball?
Now, with less than a month left in the regular season, we learn Harper supposedly has had hip pain since crashing into the outfield wall on April 29th. He stayed in the lineup in spite of hurting his ribcage that day and then played on after another date with the wall on May 13th when he hurt his left knee. As any headstrong athlete might – but especially one who is a stubborn twenty year old – Harper continued to take the field, aggressively, though less productively, until aggravating the knee with a headfirst slide on May 25th. The diagnosis was bursitis and was secondary to the trauma from contact. Harper ultimately voiced his regrets for playing hurt – doing so likely compounded his recovery time.
Well, it seems Harper was giving lip service to having learned that lesson. Only after reportedly limping around the field and base paths these last few days did he admit his sore left hip was getting in the way. Evidently the player has been receiving treatment on the hip from the training staff for an undisclosed period of time.
"Yes, I did think Aldrich was good UNTIL I SAW HIM PLAY. "- thethe
Heyward has a 968 OPS and a 368 avg vs LHP this year....so if they are platooning him, that's pretty dumb.
The Atlanta Braves signed Nick Markakis for 4/45 - Never forget 12/3/2014
"Klay Thompson > James Harden" - Heyward
"Chris Bosh is the MVP of the Miami Heat" - Heyward
"Hibbert is better than Dwight Howard"- Heyward
"Steven Adams will be a top 10 center in two years - thethe
I'm not a stand on the fence kind of guy. Makes me look bad a lot but I have my moments as well. Harper will end up being one of my good moments.
Natural Immunity Croc
He was pretty special in April of 2013 until he got hurt.
Last year was a down year early on and this year he is clearly been the best hitter in baseball almost two months into the season.
Natural Immunity Croc
This isn't a matter of "let's see if you are right...". Right now you are wrong by saying he's the best hitter in baseball. Could he become the best? Yes. Absolutely. No sane person should deny that. But you are categorically false by saying he has been the best hitter in baseball when healthy. He could hit 2000 homeruns in his career and you would still be wrong.
"Yes, I did think Aldrich was good UNTIL I SAW HIM PLAY. "- thethe
He was special in April of 2013 but he wasn't the best hitter in baseball during that month. But what you are pretty much saying is that Harper has only been healthy for 7 weeks in his MLB career, right?
He wasn't the best hitter the first half of this season. His stats are reflection of him hitting .600 the last 2 weeks.
Overall he's been the best, but all that anyone is saying that being the best hitter in baseball requires more than a solid 2 week insane hot streak.
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote