Quote Originally Posted by smootness View Post
Lewis' upside is probably pretty similar to Anderson's in terms of value. I would argue that Lewis' upside is about .270 with 35 HR in the majors offensively while playing pretty good defense. That's certainly a really valuable player, but so is a legit #2 starter. And I think the Braves determined that they think Anderson has a better chance of hitting that upside than Lewis does of hitting his.
I agree with your assessment of Lewis's upside (though I see him as able to hit in the .280ish range if he really clicks), but your description of his upside fits the bill of a 5+ WAR OF, which is much higher than a #2 starter. And I'm certain the Braves did determine that, or else I hope they did anyway. Time will tell if they are right. I certainly hope they are.