Poll: Dansby Swanson

[USMA76]

Should he be sent back to AAA? Discuss. (Everyone seems to have an opinion; I wanted to see if there's a substantial consensus.)

[Garmel]

No

[msstate7]

No, he should be sent to Rome. Really though, nah, I think he's about to get going

[UNCBlue012]

No. I want to say yes, but I think he will be fine. He's young and this is a year to let him develop. Not his fault he was rushed

[Runnin]

Not yet.

[TheBravos]

Nope

[nsacpi]

the overriding consideration to me is that you want those 6 pre free agency years to be as productive as possible...i wouldn't have called him up in the first place and would send him back down tomorrow...has nothing to do with what I think of him as a person or his potential as a player

[chipchildress]

i don't necessarily agree that the most important consideration with what might be the player they hope to be the cornerstone of their future should be service time. i actually think that should be close to the bottom of what they're considering. not with everybody necessarily, but swanson will get re-signed for a 25 year extension if he proves worth it.

for the life of me i can't figure out why people get so tied up in these savings, as if you were paying liberty media's bills. we've seen it before and we'll see it again...when the braves want to spend money they will. people jumped for joy when upton's contract was dumped but why?

swanson will either be worth a billion dollars to the braves or won't be. if he is, service time will simply not be anything close to an issue. and frankly, the team moved out to cobb county because they said they'll make a bunch of money off the deal. well, i'm not going to celebrate these guys cutting costs. f that. spend some money. anyway, i'm done pretending like it's some great accomplishment when the braves are good at being cheap.

[nsacpi]

The most amazing part is that our own GM has said the thought of promoting Swanson never crossed his mind until Hart knocked on his door one day and said hey, lets see what happens if we promote Swanson, there's nothing to lose. Amazing way to make that kind of decision. Gold standard franchise.

[nsacpi]

for the life of me i can't figure out why people get so tied up in these savings, as if you were paying liberty media's bills.

something to do with budgets and payrolls and the braves not exactly being in a position to throw money away...at least not to the extent that a lot of other teams do...for someone like me who wants to see the team be as competitive as possible, i'd like to see the money productively spent...otherwise it matters not a whit

[chipchildress]

something to do with budgets and payrolls and the braves not exactly being in a position to throw money away...at least not to the extent that a lot of other teams do...for someone like me who wants to see the team be as competitive as possible, i'd like to see the money productively spent...otherwise it matters not a whit

of course you're right....but
i'm just bitter that the braves fleeced us all with this "rebuild" which looks a lot more to me like a giant cut in spending to pay for their new stadium.

i guess i just don't buy that saving a few million dollars here and there really matters all that much in the long run to these gazillionaires, but they would never admit to it.

[chipchildress]

The most amazing part is that our own GM has said the thought of promoting Swanson never crossed his mind until Hart knocked on his door one day and said hey, lets see what happens if we promote Swanson, there's nothing to lose. Amazing way to make that kind of decision. Gold standard franchise.

except he may be right. i thought the new stadium was supposed to produce oodles of cash? again, i'm way less worried about the wallets of some mega company than others i guess. liberty media produces $5Billion annually in revenues.

but to your point, perhaps a little more thought going into the move wouldn't have been a bad idea.