Acuna straight up for....

[goosecreekbrave]

Fill in blank! One for one. Assuming current contracts.

[CyYoung31]

Mike Trout.

Did I win?

[Braves1976]

George Springer

[BeanieAntics]

This thread just gave me a damn heart attack

[msstate7]

Trea turner.

We wouldn’t have to pitch to him anymore

[The Chosen One]

Jose Altuve. Move Ozzie back to short. Buh Bye Dans!

[Carp]

Andrelton Simmons....

😔

[EstebanBugatti]

The clone of Babe Ruth that the Yankees have been working on for the past couple decades.

[jimsnores]

Current contracts? I'd take my chances on staying with Acuna.

[Enscheff]

I don’t think any player in the game currently fits the Braves needs and time line better than Acuna.

I’m not sure I’d trade him for anyone. Judge or Bryant are the only guys I would consider, and they aren’t being traded.

[goldfly]

Mike Trout.

yep

[UNCBlue012]

Yeah, Trout is about it right now.

[Knucksie]

Jose Altuve. Move Ozzie back to short. Buh Bye Dans!

That salvaged an otherwise troll bait thread!

[clvclv]

A 23 year old Chipper.

[Heyward]

There arent too many players i'd trade Acuna for.

Not even 20!!! yet, and cheap for 6-7 years if we hold him back.

Not too many players have great team-friendly deals that are elite talents.

[BeanieAntics]

There arent too many players i'd trade Acuna for.

Not even 20!!! yet, and cheap for 6-7 years if we hold him back.

Not too many players have great team-friendly deals that are elite talents.

He just turned 20 earlier this week, but yeah it would have to be an incredible deal for me to give Acuna up. I am a big believer that he will be a really good major leaguer, and we should have control of him for 7 years. There isn't a lot I would trade that for. Maybe nothing. I think it depends on what you think Acuna is going to become. Do you think he is a 2-3 WAR player? 3-4, 4-5, 5+? I think he will be a consistent 4 win player, with some seasons getting up to 5 or 6. That has an insane amount of value when you add in his control

[Heyward]

He just turned 20 earlier this week, but yeah it would have to be an incredible deal for me to give Acuna up. I am a big believer that he will be a really good major leaguer, and we should have control of him for 7 years. There isn't a lot I would trade that for. Maybe nothing. I think it depends on what you think Acuna is going to become. Do you think he is a 2-3 WAR player? 3-4, 4-5, 5+? I think he will be a consistent 4 win player, with some seasons getting up to 5 or 6. That has an insane amount of value when you add in his control

I think he'll be a consistent 5+ WAR player. Probably struggle some as a rookie but the kid is a special talent, not much if anything i'd move him for given our need for a top tier hitter.

[Hudson2]

I’m with y’all, it would take a crazy over pay to get him away from us imo. He has all the talent to be a super star. With him, Albies, Swanson, and all the young pitching we have the future is super bright.

[bravesfanforlife88]

I think he'll be a consistent 5+ WAR player. Probably struggle some as a rookie but the kid is a special talent, not much if anything i'd move him for given our need for a top tier hitter.

This....Acuna has to be considered nearly untouchable. Only way you trade him is if you are filling MULTIPLE needs with players under contracts that are impact makers. Not likely. With very few quality offensive players close to the majors, you keep Acuna.

Maybe a package built around Archer and Kiermaier...even then I don’t think I’d do a deal. Kiermaier hasn’t played more than 108 games in 3 of his 4 seasons. It would be a win now kind of trade, but I think we can win with Acuna and some of our prospects

[Braves1976]

I wasn't really advocating trading Acuna by naming Springer. I just named him to point out how untouchable Acuna is in my view. No way Houston would move Springer of course.