Hunter Renfroe

[sturg33]

No way am I trading Simmons for Renfroe.

Simmons is gone thanks to the boneheaded regime we had. Can't factor him into any decision regarding Newcomb.

(i wouldn't trade Newcomb for Renfroe, though)

[thewupk]

I wouldn't trade Newk for Renfroe but they aren't that far apart in vlaue imo. Baseball-Ref has a kinder view of his defense and he put up a 0.8 bWAR in about 3/4 of a full season. Newk had 1.1 bWAR in 2/3 of a full season. enscheff is right that we shouldn't trade any meaningful assets for Renfroe. He simply isn't worth it and the Braves should be aiming higher. Now if he could be had for a non asset like Blair then by all means but I doubt that will happen.

[bravesfanMatt]

Simmons is gone thanks to the boneheaded regime we had. Can't factor him into any decision regarding Newcomb.

(i wouldn't trade Newcomb for Renfroe, though)

I know. Just putting a sarcastic spin on it. I hated trading Simmons. He could go 0- 600 for the season and I would start him every day. He was that good. And I have thethe love for Newk. Still not worth it.