Those acquisitions put the Braves at $120M-$125M, and leave zero room for any other additions of note.
I think it's safe to assume the Braves will not be adding an impact player at 3B, and will see how Camargo/Riley (if not traded) plays out until the deadline. At that point we may see them go after someone like Arenado.
cajunrevenge (11-08-2018)
We know/think the Braves are going to make a fairly significant trade, and we assume it's either going to be for a C or cOF. That means 1 of the 2 main scenarios we see being bandied about here: Realmuto/Brantley, or Grandal/Peralta.
I would prefer Grandal/Peralta, but I think all the "acquire a TOR pitcher" smoke spewed by Bowman may point towards a 3rd scenario where the Braves trade for 2-3 years of a 3+ win SP, sign Brantley, sign a lesser catcher than Grandal, and spread more of the money around to a good LHH bench bat and some BP help.
I'd hate to see the Braves consolidate young pitching into old pitching, but it is a distinct possibility, and the one that might actually be most likely. I do think folks who say the Braves will not give up a pick for a FA with a QO may be correct, even though I don't agree with the policy.
Blurb just reported on XM said that Price may be the new Pitching Coach.
Has there EVER been a statement and question a certain someone should absolutely never have made and asked publicly more than...
Kinda pathetic to see yourself as a message board knight in shining armor. How impotent does someone have to be in real life to resort to playing hero on a message board?
Price does have a reputation for being a good pitching coach but he does come off as being unhinged mentally.
Wut, Realmuto may be a top 3 catcher, but he is only a 4 WAR player. Grandal is a 3 WAR player. Ramos a 2-3 WAR player. Hell even Zuk has been a 2 WAR player the last couple years.
Haniger is a legit 6 WAR player. The only FA OFer comparable to him is Harper, and he's nowhere near feasible for us. It would be much smarter to use our prospect currency on Haniger and sign someone like Ramos or Grandal than trade for Realmuto and sign Brantley or Pollock.
Haniger was a 4.6 WAR player in 2018.
Steamer projects him as a 2.8 player in 2019, partly due to his BABIP coming down to .305 from .336 in 2018.
"I am a victim, I will tell you. I am a victim."
"I am your retribution."
"Well, you’ll learn soon enough that this was a massive red wave landslide." - thethe on the 2020 election that trump lost bigly
“I can’t fix my life, but I can fix the world.” - sturg
Only a 4 WAR player at a position not many teams get great production from.
And Haniger may had had a career year, and given the M's got Mallex back in their trade, i'm not sure they're gonna move Haniger.
Brantley in FA and Realmuto in trade, it's gotta be one or the other, is the best bet imo and you dont lose any draft picks.
In my eyes, the draft pick is the only true downside of the Grandal/Peralta path. I like Peralta more than Brantley and Peralta carries less injury risk. I like Grandal more than Realmuto because of his framing and the fact that he's not really that big of an offensive dropoff. I also like this path because I would expect it to be the cheaper path in terms of prospects, and possibly also in terms of money if the 3/45 projections are correct for Grandal. I also like this path because even if you miss out on Grandal you could sign Ramos as the backup plan.
Losing the draft pick sucks, but lets remember that you don't lose your 1st anymore. Its a 2nd round pick which has substantially less surplus value than a 1st. I think the cost of that pick would be made up by the fact that we'd probably give up less in a Peralta deal than a Realmuto deal.
Jaw (11-08-2018)
None of that disputes what I said. You disagreed with Super that that the difference in Realmuto and FA catchers wasn't far apart. But Super was indeed correct. The diffence in Realmuto and Grandal/Ramos is roughly 1-1.5 WAR. That's not insignificant, but it isn't some massive difference either.
"Well, you’ll learn soon enough that this was a massive red wave landslide." - thethe on the 2020 election that trump lost bigly
“I can’t fix my life, but I can fix the world.” - sturg
When taking framing into account, as modern FOs assuredly do, Realmuto and Grandal are almost identical. This notion that Realmuto is superior to Grandal is perpetuated by folks who don't understand how to value catchers.
We've already seen the Braves prioritize pitch framing by letting Suzuki walk, extending Flowers, and acquiring Lopez to be the AAAA catcher. I would take that as clear evidence the Braves are properly valuing framing skills.
What about JT and Peralta. We have the prospects to do it. Money left to buy whatever we want then.
Coppy
If I were AA, I would fix the major holes at C and cOF rather quickly, and then sit back and wait for bench pieces and BP arms to drop to bargain prices at the end of the off season.
It happens every single year.
jpx7 (11-08-2018)