so the Phillies were projected ahead of the Braves after acquiring Harper. By the projection systems and most observers
They had two former starters in Nick Williams and Altherr in reserve in the OF. Williams has been an above average strong side of a platoon up to this season. He’s a more than adequate fourth of, but it’s tough to do that when you are also hurt.
Kingery is their utility man that was probably overqualified for the job and he’s played just about every position, including the of, and has been good.
They had a flawed team that was plenty good enough to make a run this year.
I thought the Braves were also plenty good enough to contend and were underrated by people who were only looking at offseason additions. Still, the standings would be tighter if Riley had not come out with what may be the best month he ever has a pro.
i felt the projections were heavy on the phillies, and potentially light on the Braves due to all of the young players. i think Ronald was projected for 4 WAR and he’s going to easily eclipse that, perhaps by 50%. stuff like that.
we’ll have to agree to disagree on Williams and Altherr. williams has always been a terrible defensive player (not bad, terrible, which is already bad lot planned as a 4th OF IMO). his small success on offense was BABIP driven. relying on him was foolish, and i would’ve said at the time (not even just hindsight) that Joyce would easily be a better option.
Altherr put up a negative WAR last year. enough said. they should have dumped him earlier and looked to upgrade. “two former starters” means nothing here.
Herrera is the only one me i give them a slight pass on. his decline was fast and sharp. however watching him a lot last year, he was clearly bad defensively. maybe they thought it was more a fluke than anything. but it was clear.
kingery was also terrible last year and is probably overperofmring a good bit. he’s likely a solid player, not a star. fine.
they signed Robertson and had Neshek under contract. what have we said all offseason here about signing RPs in general, much less old ones? they sunk a lot of “stupid money” into two old RPs. i don’t give them credit for trying; they made mistakes. with both of them. these are poor decisions.
i’ll reiterate their decision to not only have Franco on the team, but to start him. poor. decision. and i said so at the time. hindsight is not ruling me here.
their starters stayed miraculously healthy last year (as i pointed out throughout last year) and regressed heavily in the 2nd half. so what do they do? not add a single bit of depth to the rotation. not like they had decent guys in the minors just waiting for a chance. it was trash there too. their SP was bound to do them in, even if the offense were good...and it’s not. again: 19th in the entire league in wRC+ and 9th in the NL. it’s an average offense despite the names and offseason trophies.
i can’t see how they’re anything but a poorly built team. i was pretty confident they wouldn’t be the Braves downfall all year, even during their time at the top of the division.
this is the same FO that thought adding Carlos Santana at 3/60 last year was a smart move for that team. never mind that the fit was terrible. they did it. right there i stopped giving them the benefit of the doubt on team building. shockingly, simply spending “stupid money” didn’t make them good decision-makers.
"Well, you’ll learn soon enough that this was a massive red wave landslide." - thethe on the 2020 election that trump lost bigly
“I can’t fix my life, but I can fix the world.” - sturg
Managuarantano's Volunteers (07-06-2019)
Apparently one of the Mets' affiliates screwed up their fireworks celebration and ended up setting the woods on fire
Last edited by Freshmaker; 07-06-2019 at 02:31 PM.