Thanks all for the quick response regarding Anderson’s spin rate.
Chapman is exactly the type of player that Oakland keeps to maintain a competitive roster - pre-arb. Its tough to see them trading him until at least 2022.
But if they were somehow willing to move him, it would take an absolute treasure trove of assets to get him. We're talking about a guy projected to produce almost 24 WAR over the next four years who will likely make around ~50 million in his three years of arbitration. When you start to look at the costs of what a Chapman trade might look like, it becomes a lot less inspiring.
Carp (12-30-2019)
Carp (12-30-2019)
Except you hear about players taking a discount bc they either have played with the team for a while, or they genuinely love their teammates, coaches, and the city. Not weird at all. It may be rare, and happening less than it used to, but it’s certainly not weird or unheard of.
Chapman is likely a pipe dream, but even if he weren't, you aren't getting him without giving up a package including Pache. He's a 6+ WAR 3b in his prime and with 4 years of control at extremely affordable rates. Conservatively, he has about 120 million in surplus value, but you could easily argue he has as much as 150 million. A package of Pache (~55m), Anderson (~35m), and Riley(~40m) may not even be enough. He's that valuable.
The ultimate question there is "should Pache be untouchable?" That's a critical team evaluation.
But, with no comment on whether the org should move Pache or not, if you are trading a 60 prospect, then getting back a 6 win player with four years of pre-FA control is certainly the type of return you should be looking for.
Carp (12-30-2019)
It comes from here:
https://www.fangraphs.com/prospects/...ype=3&team=atl
Those RPM values are gathered second hand from scouts Kiley and Eric talk to because nobody in the public sphere has access to MiLB statcast data. That 1700 value for Anderson’s breaking ball would be the worst of any MLB pitcher.
That RPM value could be erroneous, but if it is accurate it is physically impossible for that spin rate to produce a MLB breaking ball. Cross checking past values on those lists with actual MLB values when the prospect was promoted shows they are roughly accurate historically.
Further, his reverse splits suggest he is succeeding with an MLB quality change against hitters unaccustomed to seeing them, which won’t be the case at the MLB level.
Last edited by Enscheff; 12-30-2019 at 02:19 PM.
Super (12-30-2019)
I'm skeptical this dude knows anything at all about what he's talking about. I've seen a few of his chat transcripts over the past couple months and he seems to shoot from the hip alot and most of his takes are really dumb. Doesn't really seem to follow the Braves much, so I doubt he knows what he's talking about.