Should Puig be an all star?

I'm all for Monica Puig being on the All-Star team.

8369347268_12b920e533_b.jpg
 
I don't think so, he's only been in the majors for a month. As great as that month has been I don't think that justifies an All Star selection. There will be plenty of future All Star games he will be apart of.
 
I don't think he should either. Would be kind of crappy for guys like D. Brown, Choo, Cuddyer, Fowler, McCutchen, etc. Guys that really deserve to get in.
 
At least Bryce last season was professional about Chopper deserving to get in. Puig is a punk and I want Hinske to destroy him!
 
NinersSBChamps said:
At least Bryce last season was professional about Chopper deserving to get in. Puig is a punk and I want Hinske to destroy him!
Click to expand...

If so, your best bet is to deep-fry him in a batter of 11 herbs and spices and serve him with a side of mashed potatoes.
 
rather have him than upton

and yes, puig will be voted in for the final vote.

do you even puig?
 
thethe said:
Yup, Upton doesn't deserve to be an all star.
Click to expand...

OK this is ridiculous. I'm gonna slide off the topic for a second and address this point. Stop the Justin Upton hate. Sure he's struggled the last 2 months, but he also carried us for a month and still is one of our best players. I wouldn't put him in the All-Star game but it's hardly like you can't make a case for him. He carried a .900 OPS through the beginning of June, if you want to blame anyone for him getting in (if he does) blame mlb for opening up voting on like the 3rd day of the season. Wonderdouche will wind up passinghim anyway so it won't matter Justin won't get in but the senseless hate for him is beyond ridiculous.

As far as Puig goes, eh should be an All-Star if you're not gonna name defensive boosted players like Marte and Ozuna. But the biggest hosing has to be that Cutch isn't in the top 3 in voting. I can get Carlos Gomez not being there as this year is his first year of not being highly mediocre, but Cutch has been one of the best players in the game. And can't get more votes than Wonderdouche who's missed a ton of games and Holliday who'd been good but isn't spectacular.
 
thethe said:
Yup, Upton doesn't deserve to be an all star.
Click to expand...

Plus I want the best guys there and I don't care who it is. If we somehow get to the World Series it would be nice to have home field advantage. Plus our guys need a few days off right now.
 
Justin has not been nearly as bad as his brother. I used to hate Uggla but now it is BJ. I hope all these players have a great 2nd half of the season.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top