Carp's latest activity

  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    That would be nice. I hadn't realized how consistently good Jansen has been. He's been as reliable of a reliever as just about any...
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    That is certainly fair. But I would hold that against Lopez more than I would credit him. He simply isn't used to being a starter the...
  • Carp
    I suppose this means Houston won't be trading Correa. He gives them a lot of flexibility being able to play SS and 3b, and likely OF if...
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    I suppose you could just get Texas to kick in money, without trading Lopez. And then you have DeGrom and Lopez. I just assumed the...
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    No we don't know that. Lopez threw only 135.2 innings. And while the underlying stats were good, it was the first time he had been a...
  • Carp
    Carp reacted to thewupk's post in the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread with Like Like.
    Yes. deGrom was a 3+ WAR starter in 2025. His issue is health and it's a major concern if he can throw 300+ innings over the next two...
  • Carp
    Carp reacted to bravesfanMatt's post in the thread Minor League Thread Part Deux with Like Like.
    2025 Scouting grades: Fastball: 55 | Slider: 50 | Cutter: 55 | Changeup: 45 | Control: 55 | Overall: 45 Burkhalter spent three years...
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread Minor League Thread Part Deux.
    McCabe's path to a long MLB career is to be an Eric Hinske type of player.
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    I suppose that is true. However, I could also point out that trading for deGrom and freeing up Lopez' money might allow us to sign...
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    If DeGrom pitches like he did in 2025, then yes, easily.
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    But Lopez is a likely notably worse pitcher and he is trying to return from should surgery. And he's a pitcher who has thrown over 130...
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    All pitchers are injury risks. At least the upside is pretty massive.
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    Jacob DeGrom would be sneaky good play. Maybe we could attach Lopez in the trade to help off-set some salary.
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    Seagar's contract is just so hard to absorb. I realize on the surface he would probably get 6/180 right now if he were a FA, but he's 31...
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    1 year and 16 million. Not exactly a ton of risk there. If Williams gets close to what Tanner Scott got (or better), I'll eat some...
Back
Top