⚾️On this here off-day today, how would you personally our first basemen that you've seen, from the beginning of your fandom up to present-day?⚾️

Mrs. Meta

Mrs. Meta

Well-known member
I will post my list from 1996 on when I figure out where to put Robert Fick and Rico Brogna.😌

But that said, I'm curious to see what y'all come up with, largely, and understandably, after Frederick Charles Freeman
 
Chris Chambliss for that bodacious HR he smacked against the Dodgers when I was a kid .. it was a tight pennant race (we were in the same division with them back then) and it was a back and forth tight game … and Chambliss hit a come from behind dramatic dinger at Fulton county.
Big Cat is up there too.
Come to think of it….Favorite is the Crime Dog
 
For the purposes of this exercise I only counted players who were the primary first baseman and/or played in at least 100 games in a season.

1. Freeman - still the best all around 1B we've had
2. McGriff
3. Olson - room to move up
4. Galarraga - wish we could have had him longer
5. Murphy - bonus points for being the first Braves 1st baseman I ever saw. He would've been fine there long term - the bat coming around at the time of the position change was coincidence.
6. Bream - sentimental reasons only due to the slide.
7. Chambliss
8t. LaRoche - still think Bobby should have let him face LHP earlier
8t. Franco - seems like you can't have either of these two without the other.
10. Teixiera
11. Klesko - see note from LaRoche
12. Justice - obviously lower because of the temporary nature of the position change
13. Horner - loved him when he was at 3rd, even though 1st made more sense due to size/body type.
14. Brian Hunter
15. Troy Glaus
16. Kotchman - meh
17. Gerald Perry - double meh
18. Wes Helms - who?
19. Scott Thorman
20. Robert Fick - f*ck that guy.
 
I started in 1991 so for me it goes:

Freeman
McGriff
Olson
Galarraga
Franco
LaRoche
Bream

The 00's were pretty sparse for 1B. I'd like to forget the rest of them. (or have already)
 
I grew up watching Chris Chambliss then they had Gary Roenicke for a bit then Gerald Perry.

My favorites all time

Freddie
Matty doubles
Crime dog
The Big Cat
Chambliss
Sid ‘I Slid’ Bream
Julio Franco
 
I’m partial to Big Cat, so he’ll always be be number 1 for sentimental reasons.

Freddie / Olson / McGriff in that order.

Honorable mentions to some fun part time 1B over the year: Julio Franco, April 2010 Troy Glaus, Derek Lee,

I’d prefer to forget the entire Teixeira saga even though he was incredible in his Braves stint
 
seems like McGriff and Galaragga each only had 1 very strong season.

Freeman and Olson are clearly 2 and 3 behind Jen Griffey, Sr.

Griffey, Sr.
Freeman
Olson
McGriff
Galarraga
Texeira
Klesko
Bream
Glaus
Justice
Canadian guy
47 year old guy
 
Who was the has been that they brought in to play 1B partway through the season.

Had trouble catching the ball, and the experiment didn’t last long.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top