Latest activity

  • S
    Super replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    I am not in favor of trading players at their lowest value. I’m not sure who said he has great trade value but I guess it’s straw man...
  • Jaw
    Jaw replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    Wait what? If you claim a guy off waivers you are exactly taking on that contract. Why would someone do that and not be willing to give...
  • B
    bravesfanMatt replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    So should the Braves trade Murph?? Lets ask that question. reasons for: he is making 15 million the addition of Yaz pushes him or...
  • Jaw
    Jaw reacted to mfree80's post in the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread with Like Like.
    You could be correct if the Rangers didn’t have a major need for a C in a very thin market for Catchers. Scarcity matters.
  • Carp
    Carp replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    The entire point of ALL of this, is you said Murphy easily clears 3/45. That's certainly not a sure thing with his injury. Would Texas...
  • Jaw
    Jaw reacted to Super's post in the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread with Like Like.
    I’m pushing back on the claim he has “negative” value. That’s pretty absurd.
  • Jaw
    Jaw reacted to Super's post in the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread with Like Like.
    someone would trade at least something of real value for him. Im not even sure how that’s debatable.
  • T
    thewupk replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    Another point on Yaz. He's in like the top 5% of players who pull the ball in the air. For lefties he's leaving a park that's one of the...
  • S
    Super replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    And even still, if a team is willing to give up a prospect for him, guess what? That means he doesn’t have negative value.
  • S
    Super replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    Lol deGrom is a 37 year old pitcher who’s been injured for way more than two seasons, making 2.5x what Murphy makes. Yeah, totally...
  • B
    bravesfanMatt replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    reliever WAR is undervalued in comparison to everyday players and even starting pitchers. not a fair comparison position players...
  • B
    bravesfanMatt replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    I think someone like DeGrom is another guy. If Texas put him on waivers, a few teams would probably take him.. but no team is giving...
  • S
    Super replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    So you don’t think Murphy would fetch even a 40 prospect in a trade?
  • R
    rawwr replied to the thread 2025-2026 offseason thread.
    my dude it's ok to admit you're wrong a catcher 2 years removed from a 5 WAR season who has put up more WAR even in his down years than...
  • Tapate50
    Tapate50 replied to the thread TRHLIM.
    Can’t wait. My Pillows as far as the eye can see
Back
Top