I was actually referring to if Harper only hit like he did in 2016 or 2014 last year. Would that still be the opinion of most players? No doubt that Harper has elite talent and has had ungoldy hype. Freeman has better numbers over the last 4 years and has been way more consistent. Harper has age on his side for sure. Will only be 24 next season and not even close to his prime yet whereas Freeman is now entering his.