REAL FOOTBALL Thread

Tapate50 said:
I’d put Allen over him most games, and then some games Allen loses flat out
Click to expand...

Reality there's probably 15 QBs you put on SF and they're better or not worse. That's not a good sign for a QB argument of greatness.

If SF has Josh Allen they probably go 16-1 during the regualr season, Lamar Jackson similar, Mahomes probably 17-0.
 
Seems like the scuttle butt is Pats are looking to trade out, so any team looking for a QB will be looking to trade up if that's a case.
 
zitothebrave said:
Brock Purdy is not close to the best QB over the last year and a half. Purdy is doing well, but he's not that great.

Tua's been better if you're going with QBs with multiple elite weapons, Mahomes has been better. Goff's also been better, etc.

Purdy's been the best game manager in that time frame, but he isn't trusted to win games like Mahomes, Allen, Jackson, etc. ANyone with 2 eyes can see that.
Click to expand...

Zitis eyes or Kurt warners. Hmm….
 
t3eli4135uhc1.jpeg
 
zitothebrave said:
Kurt Warner is certainly infallible. He's definitely never said anything dumb.
Click to expand...

I’ll judge what he says since he’s a hall of famer and watches tape for his job over your take. Forgive me for doing so.

How much Purdy tape have you watched or frankly tape on any qb? And no, games and replays don’t count. All 22 or you don’t really understand if a qb is making the right reads or not.
 
thethe said:
I’ll judge what he says since he’s a hall of famer and watches tape for his job over your take. Forgive me for doing so.

How much Purdy tape have you watched or frankly tape on any qb? And no, games and replays don’t count. All 22 or you don’t really understand if a qb is making the right reads or not.
Click to expand...

Whatever you want to believe man. We have stats, other reports, etc.
 
thethe said:
Zitis eyes or Kurt warners. Hmm….
Click to expand...

Maybe you'd like former MVP Cam Newton instead?

Opinions are like assholes. What Kurt Warner said doesn't have any more validity than anyone else. I would actually find it more surprising if Warner criticized Purdy.
 
Carp said:
Maybe you'd like former MVP Cam Newton instead?

Opinions are like assholes. What Kurt Warner said doesn't have any more validity than anyone else. I would actually find it more surprising if Warner criticized Purdy.
Click to expand...

Can was a physical freak. Couldn’t read a defense and once he lost the slightest bit of athleticism he was trash and was out of the league fast. So yes - warners opinion has far more value than newton.

Warner could say very blah things if he wanted but he went out of his way to show how Purdy has been awesome this year and he’s making amazing plays on the field.
 
Last edited:
Purdy look real comfortable. Fumble was unfortunate and penalties on Williams but like how the game has started.
 
SF's dominated the LOS. But it's only a 1 score game. That fumble early by CMC gonna hurt them. Looked like they were gonna go down the field and get an early opening score.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top