Keith Law's Top 25 players under age 25

Knucksie said:
As for last 2 seasons, the jury is still out on this season. He's still under the Mendoza Line.
Click to expand...

c6NLj.jpg
 
Knucksie said:
Thought that my statement explained it Anyway, the Dodgers were overpaid and disorganized. Puig practically single-handedly changed that. When healthy, Heyward found a new home in the leadoff spot. As for last 2 seasons, the jury is still out on this season. He's still under the Mendoza Line.
Click to expand...

Puig also had a 383 BABIP last year. Puig is good but not that good. And Heyward has a crappy 246 BABIP right now. That will change and so will his overall numbers. The thing with Heyward is that he's a beast on the bases and an incredible defender. He has averaged over 5 fWAR per 162 games played. The talent is there and he's shown it. The only real issue is being consistent and staying on the field. As he is he an above average hitter with amazing base running and defense which equates to one of the better players in the game when on the field.
 
thethe said:
Well, I guess thats comforting since Law has been 100% spot on in the past about the Braves.
Click to expand...

Of course he's wrong a lot. He admitted it with FF's rank. But if you celebrate his Simba ranking....

Here it is from Klaw a couple of hours after my post:

mitchell (blacksburg)

surprised wood didnt make the top 25 even after his fantastic start to the season. Do you not think he will keep it up?

Klaw (4:39 PM)

I do not, at all. Bad delivery, already blew out once, fringy breaking ball, and that hot start (SSS) comes after he lit up two bad lineups.
 
Knucksie said:
Puig should be higher too. He's still got some maturing to do, but he was the catalyst for igniting the Dodgers last season. Heyward's yet to do that with ATL.
Click to expand...

No, Puig did not single-handedly ignite them. Their pitching finally stayed consistent with all the talent they had..I mean, bought.

Heyward definitely ignited the offense last year. And he has more potential than Puig, and is an incredible defender.
 
Not sure i'd have Harper over Stanton.

Stanton is only 2 or 3 years older?

Decent list though.
 
yeezus said:
No, Puig did not single-handedly ignite them. Their pitching finally stayed consistent with all the talent they had..I mean, bought.
Heyward definitely ignited the offense last year. And he has more potential than Puig, and is an incredible defender.
Click to expand...

Puig wasnt the sole reason they improved but he helped out a lot.

One of the bigger reasons they went on their insane run.
 
Heyward said:
Puig wasnt the sole reason they improved but he helped out a lot.

One of the bigger reasons they went on their insane run.
Click to expand...

He certainly contributed. "Single-handedly" when back-to-back Cy Young winner is on the squad is a little much.
 
Heyward said:
Puig wasnt the sole reason they improved but he helped out a lot.

One of the bigger reasons they went on their insane run.
Click to expand...

Yeah because he had an insane 500 BABIP for the month of June when he came up. Puig is a good player but he's not great like he's been made out to be. He cooled off tremendously after that month as he hit 272 with a 815 OPS in his last 77 games.
 
I like that Marlins team, although they have a ways to go. Yelich has looked good against us since day 1...I think he's going to plague us for years.
 
thewupk said:
Yeah because he had an insane 500 BABIP for the month of June when he came up. Puig is a good player but he's not great like he's been made out to be. He cooled off tremendously after that month as he hit 272 with a 815 OPS in his last 77 games.
Click to expand...

Sometimes a great month can be enough to fire up a team, especially if it comes at the right time. Previously, the Dodgers got charged up over one at bat. The old timers here will recall the Kirk Gibson HR in the 1988 WS. It was his only AB during the series and he won MVP.
 
wheresmykayak said:
By that logic of "his delivery will make him blow out" (not saying I'm agreeing with that, either), then wouldn't it make sense to get maximum value out of his arm while he's good? I mean, he's clearly shown he has the skills to not only a good starter, but a dominant starter.

He's a great pitcher, his name is awesome for innuendos. He's a Georgia boy. What else do you want, really?
Click to expand...

To score the boy some runs!
 
Criticizing K. Law is pointless. It's just too easy. His Middle name should be Considerthesource.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top