GDT #28: 5/2/14 - Giants (Lincecum) at Braves (Minor); No Gattis or Uggla

NinersSBChamps said:
Oh yes this amazing prospect who can't beat Pena or Pastornicky for a roster spot. If he was as good as people say the team would find a way to get him to the roster.
Click to expand...

Ya and the Pirates couldn't use Polanco in RF cause he couldn't "beat out" Snider or Tabata on the roster. Tommy deserves a shot when you look at our other options. Not comparing Tommy to Polanco talent wise, just the principle.
 
NinersSBChamps said:
Oh yes this amazing prospect who can't beat Pena or Pastornicky for a roster spot. If he was as good as people say the team would find a way to get him to the roster.
Click to expand...

You think he hasn't been promoted because he's not better than Pena or Pastornicky?
 
Hawk said:
It's certainly more understandable at this point than the line about his arbitration clock.
Click to expand...

I don't think it's clock related. Fredi and Uggly have been on the same team for 8 seasons. He's seen the best of Uggla so I bet he's more than willing to go to bat for his boy and buy him time to improve himself. I have little doubt that at the latest of the end of this month, UGgla will be hitting, or TLS will be in the majors.

Pena and Pastor are good bench players. Both suck as starters.
 
LaStella is in AAA so he can get regular AB's. Pena and Pastor have already "proven" they're utility guys, not regulars. TLS will get the call when we pull the plug on Uggla. I don't think there much speculation in any of these three points.

Now will LaStella be better than Uggla? That's speculation. If he isn't I guess Pastornicky will get another shot.
 
There are a wide range of options between releasing Uggla and playing him every game. I'm hopeful that the game off yesterday is a sign that Fredi will start availing himself of those options.
 
stpeteirish said:
Now will LaStella be better than Uggla? That's speculation. If he isn't I guess Pastornicky will get another shot.
Click to expand...

I have a dog in my living room right now who would be better than Uggla. Probably as good a fielder, would steal some bases, and walk more and have a higher OBP dispite batting .000.
 
I agree Pena and Pastor are nothing more than utility players, but Uggla isn't even that at this point. Platoon them until Tommy or someone from the outside is brought in.
 
nsacpi said:
There are a wide range of options between releasing Uggla and playing him every game. I'm hopeful that the game off yesterday is a sign that Fredi will start availing himself of those options.
Click to expand...

What options are those? He's not a late-inning defensive replacement and I don't know if his style lends itself to pinch-hitting. Pinch-runner? Probably not. He's a one position guy who has pretty much lost any athleticism he had. He got old fast.
 
50PoundHead said:
What options are those? He's not a late-inning defensive replacement and I don't know if his style lends itself to pinch-hitting. Pinch-runner? Probably not. He's a one position guy who has pretty much lost any athleticism he had. He got old fast.
Click to expand...

Yeah, I see two options: cut or trade.
 
PurpleBrave said:
I have a dog in my living room right now who would be better than Uggla. Probably as good a fielder, would steal some bases, and walk more and have a higher OBP dispite batting .000.
Click to expand...

Well his strike zone by definition would be non existant, so of course he would walk every at bat. He would probably chase the ball when hit and be out for running out of the bade paths. Rather have him replace Milwood as a poster. I am sure what he would type would be intelligent.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top