GDT 7/23/13: Braves (Medlen) @ Mets (Torres) 7:10 PM

NYCBrave

NYCBrave

Well-known member
Braves:



1. Andrelton Simmons (R) SS

2. Jason Heyward (L) CF

3. Justin Upton (R) RF

4. Freddie Freeman (L) 1B

5. Brian McCann (L) C

6. Evan Gattis (R) LF

7. Dan Uggla (R) 2B

8. Chris Johnson (R) 3B

9. Kris Medlen (S) P

Mets:



1. Eric Young (S) LF

2. Daniel Murphy (L) 2B

3. David Wright (R) 3B

4. Marlon Byrd (R) RF

5. Ike Davis (L) 1B

6. John Buck (R) C

7. Juan Lagares (R) CF

8. Omar Quintanilla (L) SS

9. Carlos Torres (R) P
 
Our worst hitter is batting 1 and one of our best is batting 8? WTF?

Should be

Jason
Johnson
Justin
Freddie
MAc
Gattis
Uggla
Simmons

Horrible lineup Fredi (now watch us score 20 runs)
 
If Simmons is forced to hit leadoff enough, eventually he will just learn to be a good hitter.

It's just like how if you beat someone with a protractor enough times, they'll become awesome at geometry.
 
Just out of curiosity, how many people would be on board with Uggla as the lead off man instead of Simmons? I know neither is an ideal candidate, but how long can we keep trotting out someone with a .280 OBP at the top of the lineup? Plus, even though he's only hitting .195, Uggla has an OBP of .320 or so. He also wouldn't be counted on in RBI situations as much since he always fails at those, and also situational hitting situations since he can't seem to ever cut down on his swing.
 
tlroom112 said:
Braves:


1. Andrelton Simmons (R) SS
P
Click to expand...

article-1352226333973-15c0c432000005dc-5116_466x482.jpg
 
tlroom112 said:
Just out of curiosity, how many people would be on board with Uggla as the lead off man instead of Simmons? I know neither is an ideal candidate, but how long can we keep trotting out someone with a .280 OBP at the top of the lineup? Plus, even though he's only hitting .195, Uggla has an OBP of .320 or so. He also wouldn't be counted on in RBI situations as much since he always fails at those, and also situational hitting situations since he can't seem to ever cut down on his swing.
Click to expand...

Fine with that. Any non-pitcher in the starting lineup is a better option.
 
Id go with something crazy like this..

Uggla

Johnson

Upton

Freeman

McCann

Gattis

Heyward

Simmons

It wont ever happen, but Uggla walks alot, CJ leads our team in average, and Heyward drops down in a spot where he will get PLENTY of RBI chances like Uggla fails at now. Shoot. Why not? We aint scoring a lot of runs anyway.
 
tlroom112 said:
Just out of curiosity, how many people would be on board with Uggla as the lead off man instead of Simmons? I know neither is an ideal candidate, but how long can we keep trotting out someone with a .280 OBP at the top of the lineup? Plus, even though he's only hitting .195, Uggla has an OBP of .320 or so. He also wouldn't be counted on in RBI situations as much since he always fails at those, and also situational hitting situations since he can't seem to ever cut down on his swing.
Click to expand...

Uggla wouldn't be ideal, but literally ANYONE on the roster is a better option than Simmons. I imagine if Uggla could get his BA up into the .230s he might very well find himself in the leadoff role. As it currently stands, just sticking Simmons at 8 and moving everyone up one spot would be just fine.

Maybe now that Heyward is a "speedy CFer" Fredi might consider batting him leadoff?
 
jpx7 said:
If Simmons is forced to hit leadoff enough, eventually he will just learn to be a good hitter.

It's just like how if you beat someone with a protractor enough times, they'll become awesome at geometry.
Click to expand...

have to admit Simmons had some good AB's last night, even hit a few balls to the right side.
 
It's such a dead horse subject though, it's not worth it getting bent out of shape. Fredi is stuck in his ways with the lineup and it's not going to change much. If it all.
 
nobody should have expected Fredi to change the lineup after winning last night, that's his M.O. Might tweak it if its a LHP or a day game after a night game but if no one's hurt Fredi won't change much. Neither would I; look at our bench, its not exactly a wealth of underused talent right now.

Flipping CJ and Simmons might work, but don't you think CJ's success is at least partially due to the lower expectations of the 8 hole?
 
tlroom112 said:
Just out of curiosity, how many people would be on board with Uggla as the lead off man instead of Simmons? I know neither is an ideal candidate, but how long can we keep trotting out someone with a .280 OBP at the top of the lineup? Plus, even though he's only hitting .195, Uggla has an OBP of .320 or so. He also wouldn't be counted on in RBI situations as much since he always fails at those, and also situational hitting situations since he can't seem to ever cut down on his swing.
Click to expand...

I would
 
stpeteirish said:
nobody should have expected Fredi to change the lineup after winning last night, that's his M.O. Might tweak it if its a LHP or a day game after a night game but if no one's hurt Fredi won't change much. Neither would I; look at our bench, its not exactly a wealth of underused talent right now.

Flipping CJ and Simmons might work, but don't you think CJ's success is at least partially due to the lower expectations of the 8 hole?
Click to expand...

Most want to put Simmons 8th and just move everyone up a spot (making Chris 7th). If his success is because of batting 8th ('lower expectations'), couldn't you say that Simmons' failure is because of batting 1st ('higher expectations')? Either way, Simmons should be batting 7th, 8th, or 9th.
 
"Can't wait to coach third again. Thank you so much for the opportunity."

B2UA_Braves_manager.jpg


"We brought you on to manage the team, Fredi."

th
 
I know Wood is coming up Thursday to replace Maholm. But why haven't we called anyone up for the bench till then? I mean we just sent Pastornicky down but we could've brought him back by going ahead and placing Maholm on DL. If not him Mejia is on the 40-man roster so we could call him up for a few games (give us an extra right handed pinch hitter with pop).

It may not mean much but every extra player helps should a game go extra innings. I just don't see why we don't do it since Maholm is DL bound anyway. We are basically going with a 24-man roster for a few days.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top