One of the rules of thumb, Omaha steaks never has a good deal. If all you really care about if Filet Mignon (which is a dumb thing to care about as it's a pedestrian cut of beef) you can get a pound of it for like 25 bucks. What I used to do back in the day when I lived near civilization is Shop Rite would once every few months run a sale and you could get a Grassfed beef tenderloin for like 6 bucks a pound. So after you did some butchering, you had yourself a handful of filets and some lovely roasts for a cheap deal. I kept the "scraps" and made my own burger meat every few months as well. Wasn't half bad.
If you want a real treat, find a good butcher and have them recommend something to you. Or go to whole foods. Back when I lived near civilization, whole foods steaks were the way to be. You'd spend 10-15 bucks for a big cut of meat but it was tender and flavorful, because they know how to properly butcher.