I found Axelrod's quotes in the Dowd piece to be insightful. Americans seem to want change until they get it. Having been involved with campaigns (lo, though many years ago) the "change" theme always seems to resonate with someone.
Was just going to make a thread on this.
Americans don't want someone who's been in Washington too long or at all, but at the same time Americans want someone who has "experience". Can't have that experience unless you've been in the game for a while.
Americans want someone who hasn't been exposed and will stand up to the corruption and backroom deals on Capitol Hill, but Americans want someone who can compromise and make a deal with the other side. Can't do that unless you've made good friendships and connections on the Hill.
Palin had zero foreign policy credentials, yet people felt she was more qualified than Obama,a Senator at the federal level, whom was on various Subcomittees with foreign relations.
Hillary has one of the most prestigious resumes on paper that anyone running for the office has ever had, yet people think she's not qualified to be President. (I'm not endorsing Hillary btw, just saying it like it is).
Cruz has been in the Senate for 3 years now, Rand and Rubio for 5. At what point are those guys officially Washington establishment guys? I was watching O Brother and have to reference one of my favorite Pappy O'Daniel scenes.
"People like that reform (change). Hey maybe we should get us some reform too?"
"I'll reform you you soft-headed son bitch. How you gonna run reform when we're the damn incumbent?!"
Obama is the shining example for this conundrum. He came into office with the change tone, yet when the other side wouldn't move an inch to compromise with him, Americans all of the sudden decided they want him to compromise even if it means agreeing to outlandish things. Just compromise just to compromise, not even getting the best deal. Obama wins re-election, and the opposing party's top leader says it's not a mandate for anything.
Trump and Carson are two who don't have that Washington experience, yet polls suggest people like them because they are not Washington guys, but don't like them because they don't have that Washington experience.