Most dissapointing prospects

P

Preacher

Where's My Cup of Coffee?
Every year we get new exciting names added into the organization through trades/signings/draft.... but every year certain guys fall off the map and remove themselves --- or diminish --- their future with the team. Among prospects who are your biggest disappointments this year?

For me;

1. Aaron Blair

Guy was a top-100 prospect and somebody that was supposed to be able to step into a ML rotation and perform adequately this season, I think Coppy was planning on Blair fulfilling his potential and become a MOR arm for us... not only didn't that happen, but he hasn't exactly been great at AAA after being demoted either.

2. Braxton Davidson

Stlll young but the strikeouts are obscene (171Ks 402 ABs) and he's slashing .224/.338/.366.

3. Zach Bird

Not that he was a great prospect, but he was decently regarded when he came over in the HO deal and supposedly had a high-90s fastball --- if nothing else there was solid potential for a good bullpen arm. And then he went and did this; 8.87 ERA with more walks than strikeouts.
 
Andy Marte.

Saw the Mets and D-Wright and thought we're gonna have the two best 3B in baseball dueling it out for the next decade.

When he came up he looked terrible.

It worked out because Chipper ended up being solid for the next 7 years, but man I think we all thought Andruw 2005 would stay like with us for another few years and that Marte was going to be a middle of the order elite 3B.

Edit: Just realized you said this year and not all time.
 
Sims would be on mine. He ended last year on a high note and started the year the same way and then just bam back to his old ways.
 
Hudson2 said:
Sims would be on mine. He ended last year on a high note and started the year the same way and then just bam back to his old ways.
Click to expand...

Just a heads up that Sims has 2.45 ERA in Mississippi and an ERA of 2.51 over his last ten. I know he struggled in Gwinnett, but he's actually had a solid year for the most part. His [shorter] stint at Gwinett hurt him, as well as the team's horrible defense! haha
 
UNCBlue012 said:
Just a heads up that Sims has 2.45 ERA in Mississippi and an ERA of 2.51 over his last ten. I know he struggled in Gwinnett, but he's actually had a solid year for the most part. His [shorter] stint at Gwinett hurt him, as well as the team's horrible defense! haha
Click to expand...

The problem is he has 55 k / 36 bb in those 57 innings.
 
Brett Cumberland - I know it's just his first taste of pro ball, but he's not exactly off to a great start.

Lucas Herbert - Maybe the broken bone is still effecting him, but certainly he didn't have a great year.
 
weso1 said:
Brett Cumberland - I know it's just his first taste of pro ball, but he's not exactly off to a great start.

Lucas Herbert - Maybe the broken bone is still effecting him, but certainly he didn't have a great year.
Click to expand...

I was coming back to mention these guys.
 
First half of the season, I was most disappointed in Riley with all the strikeouts and lack of HRs. Was just hoping, after last season's phenomenal debut, that he would pick it up from there for a full season and have 25+ homers by now. So it was a bitter pill seeing all the strikeouts and all. Very glad to see him picking it up here over the past month or so. But my expectations of him are considerably lower now overall.
 
1- Braxton Davidson- I was hoping he'd break out this year but instead went in the other direction. Reminiscent of Cody Johnson.

2- Greg Bird- I was hoping he'd capitalize on his arm, maybe move to the pen, and look like an option as a reliever for next season. He's completely collapsed.

3- Andrew Thurman- Just never got over the bus crash.

I wouldn't include Sims as a disappointment. He's still showing incredible stuff and racking up the K's. He's just not taken the step forward everyone wanted. A lot of other guys have taken steps back.
 
weso1 said:
Brett Cumberland - I know it's just his first taste of pro ball, but he's not exactly off to a great start.

Lucas Herbert - Maybe the broken bone is still effecting him, but certainly he didn't have a great year.
Click to expand...

Herbert should never have started at Rome. He's basically jumped from High School to A ball. He wasn't ready. Should have started back out in the Gcl.
 
I'm disappointed in Blair, but I have not lost faith in him. I think he'll have a bounce back year next season. It wasn't a big decline. It was just all of the sudden major suckage.

The ones I've lost faith in are Bird, Davidson, Hebert, and Sims. Bird isn't even on the prospect radar anymore. Davidson still has a shot, but it's seeming less and less likely he's the gonna be anything more than a bench player. Hebert is looking like a career backup. Sims is looking like a future late inning reliever to me, although I still hold out some hope for him.
 
Chico said:
I'm disappointed in Blair, but I have not lost faith in him. I think he'll have a bounce back year next season. It wasn't a big decline. It was just all of the sudden major suckage.

The ones I've lost faith in are Bird, Davidson, Hebert, and Sims. Bird isn't even on the prospect radar anymore. Davidson still has a shot, but it's seeming less and less likely he's the gonna be anything more than a bench player. Hebert is looking like a career backup. Sims is looking like a future late inning reliever to me, although I still hold out some hope for him.
Click to expand...

This is an interesting thread. I agree with a lot of observations here.

I think there is an element of disappointment with players who we thought might step up, who didn't. I think Blair had a big set-back, but has a good chance to bounce back. At one time we were hearing that he could be as good as Shelby Miller was for us. Certainly part of the problem is that our system is so much stronger than it was... That guys who were once, not great, but the best we had have been passed by. They didn't develop into big time players and the new guys in the system are just better.

Of course, we knew that guys like Braxton had to step it up in order to make it, and we hoped he would. If D. Peterson had not emerged, would we be looking more closely at Davidson? Who knows.

The thing I like best is that the system is so much better that guys we were hoping for before are now afterthoughts.
 
mfree80 said:
This is an interesting thread. I agree with a lot of observations here.

I think there is an element of disappointment with players who we thought might step up, who didn't. I think Blair had a big set-back, but has a good chance to bounce back. At one time we were hearing that he could be as good as Shelby Miller was for us. Certainly part of the problem is that our system is so much stronger than it was... That guys who were once, not great, but the best we had have been passed by. They didn't develop into big time players and the new guys in the system are just better.

Of course, we knew that guys like Braxton had to step it up in order to make it, and we hoped he would. If D. Peterson had not emerged, would we be looking more closely at Davidson? Who knows.

The thing I like best is that the system is so much better that guys we were hoping for before are now afterthoughts.
Click to expand...

Yeah, putting a lot of hopes in Sims, Hursh, and Davidson was kinda depressing
 
Sims as a reliever is not a bad thing. he could notch out a very nice career that way. Not saying move him now.. but I like it as a fall back.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top