Baseball America Top 100 Released

Hudson2 said:
This all day. I’ve said all along that those 3 are untouchable but anybody else is up for grabs for Yelich.
Click to expand...

Yup. Acuna is obviously one of the top 3 prospects in baseball depending on what you value and Gohara and Wright are 1a and 1b for Braves pitching prospects and imo the 2 with the best shot at being top of the rotation guys.
 
thewupk said:
Yup. Acuna is obviously one of the top 3 prospects in baseball depending on what you value and Gohara and Wright are 1a and 1b for Braves pitching prospects and imo the 2 with the best shot at being top of the rotation guys.
Click to expand...

Yep and we can’t abandon the rebuild and trade the best 3 guys of the bunch for 1 player. We should have enough ammo from the other prospects and some of the mlb guys to get a deal done.
 
jpx7 said:
I think Jaw was referring to Anderson when saying that "anything above the low 90s seemed to consistently sail high." The only thing he mentioned about Wentz was that "the guy has an 'it' factor."
Click to expand...

Yep. I'll be shocked if Anderson amounts to much, and disappointed if Wentz doesn't have a nice career.

But I also wanted to lock up Francoeur long term and was sure Kyle Davies would turn the corner. I won't pretend to be able to scout anything by judgement, but I can say based on facts that when I saw Anderson, he went high and wild when he threw hard.
 
msstate7 said:
I hate to hate on maitan, but I will feel much better if he never amounts to much
Click to expand...

Hey, are you going to be at the MSU/USM series to open the college season? I live in Hattiesburg and will probably be going to that. Baseball America just came out with their rankings and this is the first time in a while that USM has been ranked in the preseason, so I'm fairly hyped for the season.
 
Law released his top 50. Anderson at 48, Wright at 26, and Acuna at number 1!!.... Acuna may end up being the consensus #1 overall. I'm really surprised that he left Allard off the list and put names like Wentz, Touki, and Wilson on there. I definitely think Allard took a step back, but I would still have him above all three of those guys.

Edit: He also has Gohara at 50. I'm not sure if he released that ranking yesterday or today
 
BeanieAntics said:
Law released his top 50. Anderson at 48, Wright at 26, and Acuna at number 1!!.... Acuna may end up being the consensus #1 overall. I'm really surprised that he left Allard off the list and put names like Wentz, Touki, and Wilson on there. I definitely think Allard took a step back, but I would still have him above all three of those guys.
Click to expand...

There will still be some that prefer Guerreor Jr and Ohtani. Of the 5 voters for Baseball America's top 100 they all split the #1 overall vote. But that's just splitting hairs. Acuna is clearly viewed as a beast.
 
thewupk said:
There will still be some that prefer Guerreor Jr and Ohtani. Of the 5 voters for Baseball America's top 100 they all split the #1 overall vote. But that's just splitting hairs. Acuna is clearly viewed as a beast.
Click to expand...

Oh yeah of course. I was just talking about across major publications.
 
He had to of forgotten Allard bc nobody but him would put Wentz, Touki, and Wilson in front of Allard.
 
Russ2dollas said:
I never doubted the Anderson pick. My beef was with the meaningless wins that kept us from having the second pick. I wanted Senzel and we should have had him. Once he was gone I was good with Anderson.
Click to expand...

Anderson did save us over 2 million in slot money over Senzel. So if we would have picked Senzel we likely could have only had 1 of Wentz, Wilson, Cumberland, and Muller. So I guess the binary would be would you rather have Anderson and those 4, or Senzel and Wentz. I still probably fall in the camp of preferring Senzel.
 
BeanieAntics said:
Anderson did save us over 2 million in slot money over Senzel. So if we would have picked Senzel we likely could have only had 1 of Wentz, Wilson, Cumberland, and Muller. So I guess the binary would be would you rather have Anderson and those 4, or Senzel and Wentz. I still probably fall in the camp of preferring Senzel.
Click to expand...

How much more slot money do you have picking one slot higher.
 
Hudson2 said:
Allard is still a no doubt top 75 prospect in baseball regardless of who’s list it is. Also Acuna is #1 again on another list. Chipper called him the next Trout and said there’s nothing he doesn’t do great.
Click to expand...

Well if Chipper said so!!
 
BeanieAntics said:
Anderson did save us over 2 million in slot money over Senzel. So if we would have picked Senzel we likely could have only had 1 of Wentz, Wilson, Cumberland, and Muller. So I guess the binary would be would you rather have Anderson and those 4, or Senzel and Wentz. I still probably fall in the camp of preferring Senzel.
Click to expand...

I don't think the answer to this is even a debate, especially given the benefit of hindsight.
 
mqt said:
The consensus seems to be that his fastball isn't very good, and that he was getting away with stuff that flies in the minors but will eventually be an issue in the Majors.

What surprises me is believing in Touki enough to put him in the Top 100 but only having Gohara 50th. You'd think whatever methodology allows you to rank Touki would put Gohara really high.
Click to expand...

It is strange. Especially with Gohara already having mild success in his first stint in the majors. Assuming he stays healthy, I think Gohara has both a high floor and a high ceiling.
 
Carp said:
It is strange. Especially with Gohara already having mild success in his first stint in the majors. Assuming he stays healthy, I think Gohara has both a high floor and a high ceiling.
Click to expand...

Gohara has concerns with that change. He has weight issues. Klaw has mentioned concern with alcohol and if that crops up with wealth and pressure.

I think Gohara is ranked well at 50.
 
BeanieAntics said:
Anderson did save us over 2 million in slot money over Senzel. So if we would have picked Senzel we likely could have only had 1 of Wentz, Wilson, Cumberland, and Muller. So I guess the binary would be would you rather have Anderson and those 4, or Senzel and Wentz. I still probably fall in the camp of preferring Senzel.
Click to expand...

I don't think anyone is going to take Anderson, Wentz, Cumberland, Mueller over Senzel and Wentz.

Plus the winning was just dumb to begin with. Even if we would have screwed the pick up and picked Anderson at 2 we would have had a million more to spend.
 
I think Anderson is going to disappoint a lot of people. There are some legitimate control issues there and I don't think the stuff is quite as high end as you read some places (I think the 92-94 is more accurate than the 95-98). I could easily see him fall into the Matt Wisler mold.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top