The Official Thread of Pachemonium

I wasn’t saying he was like Ozzie. I said he has the tools to be another star like Ozzie. Defensive wizard who is no slouch with the bat. I think his power will come
 
BeanieAntics said:
To be fair, he did say a 55 FV hit tool which is what Fangraphs had him at. So his statement was true, depite me disagreeing with him.
Click to expand...

I just told him to take it easy. I didn't say he was wrong.

Fangraphs thinks he's a generational defender. Their projection is that he'll be a very valuable MLB player even if he never becomes an average MLB player. But they think he has the potential to be average or better and that he has a possibility of being much better than that. That's makes a really valuable prospect, but his Acuna potential as a hitter is pretty unlikely.

That's why I think being happy with Inciarte+ production is reasonable position to take.
 
bravesfanMatt said:
I wasn’t saying he was like Ozzie. I said he has the tools to be another star like Ozzie. Defensive wizard who is no slouch with the bat. I think his power will come
Click to expand...

I'm just saying he's not a natural comparison to Ozzie, because Ozzie was NEVER a slouch with the bat. Ozzie has in fact been fairly dominant with his bat for his entire career (including in MLB), minus a little time in AAA at 19.

Just like he's not a natural comparison to Acuna, for the same reason.

IF you make that comparison, the assumption on the other end is going to be an offensive value that Pache has no demonstrated thus far.

Maybe his defense does put him on a similar level of prospect status, but those aren't natural comparisons to me.
 
Southcack77 said:
1. In a relatively insignificant sample.
2. Acuna's stat line as a hitter bear no semblance of similarity to Pache. Acuna was a much better hitter, showing much more power, at an early age than Pache.

I hope his "poor mechanics" have been solved and he's great now. Let's take a look at the end of the season and see how he progressed.

I'll be pulling for you to be correct.
Click to expand...

I wasn't comparing them one on one, but so far he's made a huge jump and some (including me) were laughing at Acuna getting a fast promotion last year out of A+ due to the issues that were there for him there. I'm doubting we see the same thing but so far, my thinking that Pache's finally breakout is this year is correct and I'm not making the same mistake I made last year when Pache does go to AA in saying it might be a mistake.

AA has said "I won't rush guys" but based on what we've seen so far, we're likely 2 weeks, maybe even less of Pache continuing this to him going to AA. As he's not as aggressive, but he already surprised me with Kyle Muller going to A+ (which fwiw, I think is a mistake for it to be that early, but I don't run an organization).
 
Enscheff said:
LOL

It's like watching the three stooges argue.

Thanks for the morning chuckle guys!
Click to expand...

I just have fun and dream. Baseball is an escape for me. Fandom, by definition, is irrational. You are rooting for people you have no connection with (in most cases) in something over which you have no control.

I know the likelihood of Pache ever being an All-Star, much less a perennial All-Star, is slim. I know Ronald will likely never be better than Mike Trout.

Fandom should be about fans being irrational together for the purpose of a common goal. It shouldn't involve absolute dicks like you ruining it for everyone. I have no problem with people arguing with my posts. I'm just having fun at the end of the day.

What I do have a problem with is your INCESSANT bullying, harassment, and abuse of thethe. I have a problem with you attacking the intelligence of other posters. I have a problem with you insulting entire regions of decent, hard-working people.

I mean, look at your signature. You are so insecure and pathetic.
 
GeorgiaGirl said:
I wasn't comparing them one on one, but so far he's made a huge jump and some (including me) were laughing at Acuna getting a fast promotion last year out of A+ due to the issues that were there for him there. I'm doubting we see the same thing but so far, my thinking that Pache's finally breakout is this year is correct and I'm not making the same mistake I made last year when Pache does go to AA in saying it might be a mistake.

AA has said "I won't rush guys" but based on what we've seen so far, we're likely 2 weeks, maybe even less of Pache continuing this to him going to AA. As he's not as aggressive, but he already surprised me with Kyle Muller going to A+ (which fwiw, I think is a mistake for it to be that early, but I don't run an organization).
Click to expand...

Great post.
 
SJ24 said:
What I do have a problem with is your INCESSANT bullying, harassment, and abuse of thethe. I have a problem with you attacking the intelligence of other posters. I have a problem with you insulting entire regions of decent, hard-working people.

I mean, look at your signature. You are so insecure and pathetic.
Click to expand...

He has to run others down so he can feel superior to them. It is pathetic.
 
SJ24 said:
I just have fun and dream. Baseball is an escape for me. Fandom, by definition, is irrational. You are rooting for people you have no connection with (in most cases) in something over which you have no control.

I know the likelihood of Pache ever being an All-Star, much less a perennial All-Star, is slim. I know Ronald will likely never be better than Mike Trout.

Fandom should be about fans being irrational together for the purpose of a common goal. It shouldn't involve absolute dicks like you ruining it for everyone. I have no problem with people arguing with my posts. I'm just having fun at the end of the day.

What I do have a problem with is your INCESSANT bullying, harassment, and abuse of thethe. I have a problem with you attacking the intelligence of other posters. I have a problem with you insulting entire regions of decent, hard-working people.

I mean, look at your signature. You are so insecure and pathetic.
Click to expand...

i don't disagree with any of this. people are fans in different ways, and i know i'm definitely very optimistic very often, and wrong a lot because of it. but it's fun, and who cares about being wrong on how a player will end up? there's just no reason to take any of this that seriously as a message board poster.
 
GeorgiaGirl said:
I wasn't comparing them one on one, but so far he's made a huge jump and some (including me) were laughing at Acuna getting a fast promotion last year out of A+ due to the issues that were there for him there. I'm doubting we see the same thing but so far, my thinking that Pache's finally breakout is this year is correct and I'm not making the same mistake I made last year when Pache does go to AA in saying it might be a mistake.

AA has said "I won't rush guys" but based on what we've seen so far, we're likely 2 weeks, maybe even less of Pache continuing this to him going to AA. As he's not as aggressive, but he already surprised me with Kyle Muller going to A+ (which fwiw, I think is a mistake for it to be that early, but I don't run an organization).
Click to expand...

I thought AA was going to slow the train down for a minute, but looks like nothing much has changed.

Muller was a little behind due to the late start, so I maybe see that one.
 
Anyway, if there's a lesson to be taught here, if Pache pans out down the road as a legit starter, it is indeed about how many more position player prospects pan out, even if it's not as stars, than pitchers.

Heck, even this year's team should show it. If Albies and Acuna continue to look like young stars and Swanson is at least an average regular, that's 3 of 3 (and some thought for a while that they were the true top 3 prospects in the organization...back in 2016). Even Camargo, who may not be a regular, looks like he's going to be useful as a bench player.
 
SJ24 said:
I just have fun and dream. Baseball is an escape for me. Fandom, by definition, is irrational. You are rooting for people you have no connection with (in most cases) in something over which you have no control.

I know the likelihood of Pache ever being an All-Star, much less a perennial All-Star, is slim. I know Ronald will likely never be better than Mike Trout.

Fandom should be about fans being irrational together for the purpose of a common goal. It shouldn't involve absolute dicks like you ruining it for everyone. I have no problem with people arguing with my posts. I'm just having fun at the end of the day.

What I do have a problem with is your INCESSANT bullying, harassment, and abuse of thethe. I have a problem with you attacking the intelligence of other posters. I have a problem with you insulting entire regions of decent, hard-working people.

I mean, look at your signature. You are so insecure and pathetic.
Click to expand...

I'm sorry Taylor.

Here. Hold this, and take it to daddy...

F0PSUwu.jpg
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top