I was critical of the Stewart fiasco; and even though it looks like it will work out in the Braves’ favor, it still speaks to a lapse in due dilligence. How much of that is on Anthopoulos, versus the recently departed farm guys, is hard to parse.
Otherwise, I think Anthopoulos was quite shrewd with his midseason moves last year, in a surprise run to the Division Title. I think the Donaldson and (to a lesser extent) McCann signings are underrated moves around here; while the retention of Markakis, in lieu of a real upgrade to cOF, is both understandable and distasteful. I can’t fault Anthopoulos, however, for refusing to trade draft capital for short-term, high-dollars deal for aging pitchers, as so many seem to be doing—particularly in the context of the confluence of importance for this year’s draft (the Stewart hiccup, the upward trajectory of the team, and especially the persistent international sanctions he inherited). Trading that draft capital for Pollock would’ve been more defensible, but still risky in multiple ways.
Not a perfect score, for sure; but overall more positive than negative from my vantage. I’m willing to withhold real judgment, though, until Anthopoulos works through at least one full year with expectations under his tenure.