Bravos acquire C-Doumit from Twins for Gilmartin.

yeezus said:
Leave it to people here to complain about trading a guy who would be lucky to be a #5 to get a good bench bat back. Gilmartin will be lucky to be a long reliever in this league. It was a miss on a draft pick. Acknowledge it and move on.
Click to expand...

So your preference is to sell low on a bad year, rather than let the prospect rebuild value? Makes sense.....
 
BRule said:
So your preference is to sell low on a bad year, rather than let the prospect rebuild value? Makes sense.....
Click to expand...

We have plenty of prospects that are building value now. No certainty Gilmartin recovers. We need value on the major league team and the only way Gilmartin was going to give that this year was by trading him.
 
Doumit pretty much replaces what Gattis was for us last year.

And Hale, Martin, Northcraft, Cabrera among others have passed him.
 
nsacpi said:
I don't think Doumit will play much catcher unless there is an injury or someone turns into a pumpkin. But he will be a very useful pinch hitter. His presence will also allow Fredi to use Gattis as a pinch hitter when he isn't starting. Plus we now have our DH for interleague and the WS.
Click to expand...

So now with the addition of Doumit, what would you predict for our bench?
 
Good trade for both teams. Hopefully Gilmartin can crack the Twins rotation sometime soon. Doumit has power and can play multiple spots on the field. Best at catching, but is an upgrade in left field over Gattis too.

I don't see this as a pre cursor to a big deal either, but that's fine. Good trade and I like it for both teams.
 
KeithLockhart said:
We have plenty of prospects that are building value now. No certainty Gilmartin recovers. We need value on the major league team and the only way Gilmartin was going to give that this year was by trading him.
Click to expand...

Glad you brought up "no certainty"....Doumit has averaged 75 games player per year, for his career. He's always hurt and now has the concussion thing....just don't get why we wanted him.
 
BRule said:
Glad you brought up "no certainty"....Doumit has averaged 75 games player per year, for his career. He's always hurt and now has the concussion thing....just don't get why we wanted him.
Click to expand...

He will be a bench player. He'll be lucky if he plays 40 games this year.
 
FWIW, Doumit has apparently said he no longer wants to catch. Good for us if so because he is terrible at it. I am okay with him as a bench bat we give an occasional start in left field, assuming he hits enough. I just don't want him catching or starting games in right field.
 
I'm OK with this, and I see it as your classic "helps both teams" move. Gilmartin provided some depth for us, and that has value considering the youth and injury questions associated with our rotation, but only so much. Doumit had been a really solid hitter for three straight years before last season and for five of six before that as well. He provides some insurance at catcher, some depth in the outfield and a solid enough bench bat.

The Twins don't really have a need for Doumit, and he is getting up there in years. Meanwhile, their pitching staff has been execrable for a while, and it makes sense for them to take a shot on a young-ish lefty developing into a reasonable fourth starter.
 
BRule said:
Glad you brought up "no certainty"....Doumit has averaged 75 games player per year, for his career. He's always hurt and now has the concussion thing....just don't get why we wanted him.
Click to expand...

He will be fine coming off the bench.
The org. clearly felt it was time to move on from Gilmartin. They've watched him and know him far better than you do. We won't miss him. He will be lucky to be a long-reliever for more than a season in the MLB. Even if it all pans out for him, he's a #5.
 
Chavez signs with the DBacks, per MLBTR.

In the end, Heyman reports (via Twitter) that he preferred to stay close to his Phoenix home.

From MLBTR.

Frank's fault though.
 
Gilmartin, 23, entered the season ranked as the Braves' No. 4 prospect (per Baseball America) heading into the 2013 season. Though he suffered a down year, BA still ranked him 10th among Braves prospects, and MLB.com's Jonathan Mayo kept his ranking strong at No. 4 despite the poor season.

Gilmartin struggled through injuries and posted a 5.06 ERA across three levels in 2013, averaging 6.9 K/9 and 2.8 BB/9 in a total of 105 innings. Selected with the No. 28 overall pick in the 2011 draft, Gilmartin draws praise for his polish from both BA and MLB.com. BA writes that his 89-91 mph fastball has good movement and is complemented by a plus changeup and a slider with "sharp, late break." According to Mayo, "[Gilmartin's] ceiling is somewhat limited, but he's not far from being ready to step in as a middle-of-the-rotation type in the big leagues."
 
BRule said:
So your preference is to sell low on a bad year, rather than let the prospect rebuild value? Makes sense.....
Click to expand...

Gilmartin is barely even considered a prospect in my eyes. We lost literally nothing. There's nothing to rebound to
 
I like adding Doumit for the bench but part of me is pissed off that they wasted a pick on Gilmartin in the first place. I didn't bitch too much because Minor worked out but I am gonna be pissed if they waste another first round pick on a 5th starter/AAAA fodder.
 
Love the move. Gilmartin wasn't in the future plans even though this years numbers had more to do with his injuries than anything else. He will probably end up being another Scott Diamond but we needed bench depth. It also allows Freddi to be more flexibile with injuries. You could now put Heyward in CF against some pitchers and put Gattis in LF while Doumit catches. Solid move.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top