How Would You Fix the Playoffs?

CyYoung31 said:
I agree, but our fans are the ones tossing garbage.
Click to expand...

Which is unacceptable, but then again when has Philly had a call go against them in a series like that, much less two in the same game? Let them have a BS call or two go against them in critical situations in CBP and watch how they behave.
 
DirkPiggler said:
Which is unacceptable, but then again when has Philly had a call go against them in a series like that, much less two in the same game? Let them have a BS call or two go against them in critical situations in CBP and watch how they behave.
Click to expand...

They would absolutely do the same thing, even though the CI call was correct in the end.

I’m just annoyed their fans are so much louder and engaged than the Braves fans. It creates a legit advantage
 
Super said:
They would absolutely do the same thing, even though the CI call was correct in the end.

I’m just annoyed their fans are so much louder and engaged than the Braves fans. It creates a legit advantage
Click to expand...

If the braves are tied or winning, it'll be a different story. It's easy to be rowdy when you winning
 
Super said:
They would absolutely do the same thing, even though the CI call was correct in the end.

I’m just annoyed their fans are so much louder and engaged than the Braves fans. It creates a legit advantage
Click to expand...

I was at the game, so the only replays I saw were on the jumbotron. It didn't look like Murphy's glove moved at all...I can't imagine not seeing at least a slight movement if there was interference. But they were only showing one angle on all the in-stadium replays.

What about the Ozzie SB call overturn? It looked like the SS's glove hit dirt prior to making contact with the runner, allowing Ozzie to touch the base first.
 
DirkPiggler said:
I was at the game, so the only replays I saw were on the jumbotron. It didn't look like Murphy's glove moved at all...I can't imagine not seeing at least a slight movement if there was interference. But they were only showing one angle on all the in-stadium replays.

What about the Ozzie SB call overturn? It looked like the SS's glove hit dirt prior to making contact with the runner, allowing Ozzie to touch the base first.
Click to expand...

Part of the extra lacing hanging off his glove was hit. Jomboy had a breakdown of it. Lame, it didn’t effect the swing, but technically is CI.

The Ozzie CS I’m less convinced on. I haven’t seen any angles showing it should be overturned.
 
Option 1: LDS seven games
Option 2: All LDS games at higher seed, combined with WC series going back and forth every game to force more travel.
Option 3: Make the regular season mean something again. Two divisions each league, LCS and World Series.
 
Now you guys are defending deplorable behavior by claiming the umps wronged you.

Ozzie was out despite a single view not being clear. They use time synced composite views.

Murphy allowed part of his glove to be hit. The rule is as clear as day, and clearly broken no matter your feelings.

Get over it. Stop whining. That’s what losers do. Winners come back out the next day and stop hitting terribly.
 
I had an idea for the playoffs and making it more fair. What about for every 5 games you finish the regular season behind your post season opponent you lose 1 home playoff game.
 
Enscheff said:
Now you guys are defending deplorable behavior by claiming the umps wronged you.

Ozzie was out despite a single view not being clear. They use time synced composite views.

Murphy allowed part of his glove to be hit. The rule is as clear as day, and clearly broken no matter your feelings.

Get over it. Stop whining. That’s what losers do. Winners come back out the next day and stop hitting terribly.
Click to expand...

I'll venmo you $500 right now if you can show me one post where I defended throwing trash on the field.

If it had been a one run game the calls could be a valid complaint. There are times when that makes the difference.

Letting a mediocre at best starting pitcher look like a Hall of Famer was definitely the more relevant issue.
 
DirkPiggler said:
I'll venmo you $500 right now if you can show me one post where I defended throwing trash on the field.

If it had been a one run game the calls could be a valid complaint. There are times when that makes the difference.

Letting a mediocre at best starting pitcher look like a Hall of Famer was definitely the more relevant issue.
Click to expand...

DirkPiggler said:
but then again when has Philly had a call go against them in a series like that, much less two in the same game?
Click to expand...

Sorry if that sounded like a “yeah but what about” to me.

I’m not here to argue semantics. I’m here in an attempt stop the conspiracy theory whining.

The umps are not against the Braves. The replay officials are not against the Braves. MLB is not against the Braves. The system was not devised to hinder the Braves.

The offense didn’t show up, and they lost. Anyone saying anything other than that is being nothing more than a sore loser.
 
Enscheff said:
Sorry if that sounded like a “yeah but what about” to me.

I’m not here to argue semantics. I’m here in an attempt stop the conspiracy theory whining.

The umps are not against the Braves. The replay officials are not against the Braves. MLB is not against the Braves. The system was not devised to hinder the Braves.

The offense didn’t show up, and they lost. Anyone saying anything other than that is being nothing more than a sore loser.
Click to expand...

Fair, I guess, but it was more of a "Philly fans are trash too...they just haven't had the controversial call to give them reason to show it yet" rather than condoning it.
 
I like the idea of tightening that bye-break by having the DS start the day after the first round. If you want a day off, win the first two. The DS should be all at the home team's stadium. And enough with all the off days in between these games. It's ridiculous. These playoffs need to be as tight as the regular season to favor the deeper teams. If you don't get a bye you may have to play in 8 in a row. This is done ALL THE TIME in the regular season.
 
I don't really care about reseeding. In fact it seems to give a WC team a 2 day off advantage if they win their series in 2 games and it takes the other team 3 games to win theirs.

IMO, keep the seeds how they are, but the WC round teams get no days off. Not even a travel day between the division series. That way the top 2 seeds only have, at most 3-4 days off between the end of regular season and game 1 of the NLDS. This also keeps the WC rounds teams from having a chance to reset their rotation or get an extra day to rest their BP. And no off days between game 1 and 2 of the NLDS either.
 
Last edited:
Carp said:
I don't really care about reseeding. In fact it seems to give a WC team a 2 day off advantage if they win their series in 2 games and it takes the other team 3 games to win theirs.

IMO, keep the seeds how they are, but the WC round teams get no days off. Not even a travel day between the division series. That way the top 2 seeds only have, at most 3-4 days off between the end of regular season and game 1 of the NLDS. This also keeps the WC rounds teams from having a chance to reset their rotation or get an extra day to rest their BP. And no off days between game 1 and 2 of the NLDS either.
Click to expand...

This is me too... I initially thought reseeding, but I agree, I don't like the wait if another series goes all 3. The hard part is MLB and TV is going to want to have only 2 teams going in Division series each night. So the WC series would have to go Tuesday and the other on Wed. Then the Division series could start Friday and Sat. That still leaves a lot of days off for the bye team, but at least the WC team can't reset... I think this is the best option.
 
The teams who received a bye this year are now 2-6 in the DS. Could have easily been 1-7 if not for the Braves miraculous comeback.
 
I like the idea of the wild card round lasting 2 days. You have a double header on day one and then a normal game on day 2 if needed. The day after that you start the division series. This gives a big advantage to the top seeded teams as they get to rest up for a couple of days and set their rotation while the wild card teams have their pitching staffs wrecked and don't get to throw either of their top 2 pitchers until probably game 3.

I also like the idea of playoff double headers.
 
bravesfanMatt said:
This is me too... I initially thought reseeding, but I agree, I don't like the wait if another series goes all 3. The hard part is MLB and TV is going to want to have only 2 teams going in Division series each night. So the WC series would have to go Tuesday and the other on Wed. Then the Division series could start Friday and Sat. That still leaves a lot of days off for the bye team, but at least the WC team can't reset... I think this is the best option.
Click to expand...

In that scenario, Top 2 WC teams play first the day after the end of the season with no off days until after Game 2 o the NLDS. The lowest win NL Division winner gets a day off before starting their Wild card series and then no off days. That way the team with the best record still gets an advantage in terms of days off. I realize it's tough to schedule 4 playoff games on the same day for peak viewership. But if you start games at eastern times of 4, 6, 8, and 10 then I feel like viewership wouldn't really be that affected.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top