Search results

  1. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    I still think we might dump Lopez in the right trade. He has no real trade value, but I think he's got enough upside that someone would be willing to take him to off-set some salary in the right trade.
  2. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    I'll fax one right over. Or I mean you could simply not keep arguing the point after he signed for 25 million less than the 3/45 you thought he was gonna get. But I guess I'll settle for this post.. The point about Murphy is that he hasn't been healthy or performing like the best catcher in...
  3. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    The point of me posting "About that 3/45 projection..." was busting your balls about you being wrong. Yet your follow up post surely opens up a lot of ambiguity on whether or not you are admitting you were wrong. It's certainly arguable whether or not Murphy right now is worth more than Kim...
  4. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    He took 25 million less? Seems unlikely, but ok. And yes, his season this year is directly why I questioned whether he would get 3/45 right now. And it's why I compared his situation last year to Murphy right now, given that Murphy didn't have a timeline for return and he's been pretty...
  5. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    Folks, 2 months ago, Eli White was expected to be first bat off bench and our best utility player, and was probably going to get 500ish PAs.
  6. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    Off-season is firmly a success.
  7. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    If we're not gonna spend much more in FA, then I think Peralta makes the most sense in a trade for a SP. We should be able to get him without giving up either Cam or Fuentes.
  8. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    About that 3/45 projection...
  9. Carp

    Movie Thread

    Son was just arrested. Never understood how you could hurt a family member.
  10. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    Maybe. Probably. But the Royals still seem to have gotten by far the better end of the deal.
  11. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    It's a decent gamble. But Collins isn't likely gonna be a 2-3 fWAR player. But they gave up essentially nothing.
  12. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    That's because he doubts whether Acuna even loves baseball.
  13. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    If we bring in another SP as reported that we want to, Elder is no better than the 7th SP. Really, he's more like 8th or 9th when you consider Holmes and the rookies. He's probably traded by the end of ST.
  14. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    Abrams is probably the worst defensive SS in baseball. Doubt that happens.
  15. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    That isn't what I said.
  16. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    56 innings isn't really enough data to tell whether or not he figured it out. And even if he has figured it out, what exactly does figuring it out mean? It's unlikely he is an Ace level pitcher. So is he more Logan Gilbert or is he more Bryce Miller? Both are valuable pitchers (or at least they...
  17. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    I doubt Elder ends the year on this team. I could even see him getting traded towards the end of ST if he doesn't show out.
  18. Carp

    REAL FOOTBALL Thread

    It certainly appears like the Falcons won't miss their first rounder they traded away. Pearce looks like a stud. Might finish with 10+ sacks as a rookie.
  19. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    We at least have the makings of a good pen: Iggy Suarez Lee Holmes Bummer Wentz (I would assume since he's out of options) Last man (Dodd, Hernandez, Harris, Lara, or whoever wins this spot in ST). We also have Jimenez, but who knows when/if he'll be back. And then there is Lopez, who...
  20. Carp

    2025-2026 offseason thread

    I believe I did when I answered:
Back
Top