This is such a bizarre comparison.
The 2012 Phillies—the year they fell off—didn’t have a single member of their offensive core who wasn’t old as balls. Ruiz/Howard/Utley/Rollins/Victorino had an average age of 32.4. The conversation was explicitly “how long can this OLD ASS TEAM hang together.” (link)
The only member of our offensive core who is even in his 30s is Olson. We have a future HOF superstar entering his age 28 season. We have two recent ROYs entering their age 25 seasons. This is a complete apples to eggplants comparison.
You may want to take a moment and read what I actually wrote. I said at the end of the window, not when the window was closed. This team is very clearly on the downslope of the contention window. I very clearly said those conversions start 1-2 years from now…not now.
Pull your head out of your ass and give up trying to pull off the “gotcha” moment.