8/21 ECLIPSE MONDAY MINORS FINAL ... Collmenter is lights out again

Enscheff said:
Probably. I can't get any real info on how hard he consistently throws.

What I do know is when these guys get to Atlanta they end up throwing significantly softer than the prospect reports claim. Newk was billed as a 95-97 monster who now averages 93. Sims was supposedly a 95+ guy who now averages 91. Fried was reportedly in the upper 90s earlier this year and impressing everyone, now he's around 93 out of the BP when he can let it fly for 1-2 innings.

So yes, Allard probably does average 90 MPH because his scouting report says "His fastball will sit in the low-90s, with the ability to reach back for a little more when needed."

Do you have some other data I've never seen? Or is this just another post of yours with nothing to contribute other than a contrarian comment?
Click to expand...

You basically toss out a prospect over one velocity report from one game, and then you jump on me for contributing nothing other than a contrarian comment? Lulz.

And where were you getting your scouting reports?

Here's one from the day Sims was promoted to Atlanta saying he usually sits 91 or 92 on his fastball - https://www.talkingchop.com/2017/7/...ort-atlanta-braves-call-up-major-league-debut. Where has he been in Atlanta? 91 or 92.

Here's one from 6 months ago on Newcomb that said he had worked 92-95 in the past and had dropped to 90-93 as he was working on command - https://tomahawktake.com/2017/02/06/atlanta-braves-scouting-report-lhp-sean-newcomb/2/. Where has he been in Atlanta? 93-94. And even in Atlanta, he has touched 97 plenty.
 
Knucksie said:
What has the world come to when a starting pitcher only has to go 5 innings to be considered lights out?
Click to expand...

Welcome to the wonderful new world!!!

6 innings with a mid-3s ERA makes you a "stud", and if 60%+ of your starts are "quality starts", you're really solid.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top