DOB: Upton will be moved, Gattis very possibly as well

VirginiaBrave said:
Great news to hear all the way around. Gattis is not a big league defensive player regardless of position. Time for him to be what he is, a DH.
Click to expand...

Let's just make double dang sure that the new commissioner doesn't try to ramrod the DH through to both leagues. Stranger things have happened.
 
LOL Gattis is a fine defensive C.
If we have to deal him I understand. He's more valuable at DH.
 
I wouldn't deal Gattis.

I would trade Upton, don't know if I'd include Minor though. His value has never been lower. I would trade some other options but I don't think we'll get fair return for MM.

What I would try to do is Upton and Bethancourt for someone. I know it will upset some but I don't think Bethancourt will ever hit enough.
 
zitothebrave said:
I wouldn't deal Gattis.

I would trade Upton, don't know if I'd include Minor though. His value has never been lower. I would trade some other options but I don't think we'll get fair return for MM.

What I would try to do is Upton and Bethancourt for someone. I know it will upset some but I don't think Bethancourt will ever hit enough.
Click to expand...

There's an extremely small chance he ever hits enough, and it's not like his defense was great when he was up. If he has value, take advantage.
I agree on Minor. Selling low is never smart.
 
Board's thoughts on:

BJ Upton
Mike Minor

for

Tim Lincecum

no money changing hands.

Would we do it? Would SF do it?
 
sturg33 said:
Board's thoughts on:

BJ Upton
Mike Minor

for

Tim Lincecum

no money changing hands.

Would we do it? Would SF do it?
Click to expand...

I think it would be really silly to throw Minor away like he's worthless.
Lincecum is as bad as BJ. Though we'd only have him through next season.
 
rico43 said:
Let's just make double dang sure that the new commissioner doesn't try to ramrod the DH through to both leagues. Stranger things have happened.
Click to expand...

I think a compromise might be coming on that front. Might see DH in all inter league action but not in NL games. I would be ok with that. It's as close as we can get to satisfying everybody.
 
Well, it's basically trading Minor for $23M, and a hope and a prayer that Roger could made Lincecum relevant again
 
yeezus said:
LOL Gattis is a fine defensive C.
If we have to deal him I understand. He's more valuable at DH.
Click to expand...

Fine defensive catcher...LOL!!! He lets more balls through him than a basketball hoop. He doesn't move well and watch him run, it's only a matter of time until his legs are gone.
 
yeezus said:
There's an extremely small chance he ever hits enough, and it's not like his defense was great when he was up. If he has value, take advantage.
I agree on Minor. Selling low is never smart.
Click to expand...

I think Bethancourt at worst case is Henry Blance. He's excellent defensively. But I don't think he'll ever live up to his max ceiling (Yadier Molina) cause I don't see him doing it.
 
The biggest issue with this team is a brutal offense. I don't see any reason to trade one of our better bats in Gattis.
 
What good is it for DOB to write that Upton will be moved while he's still here? I see this ending badly.

I'm no B. Upton fan, but I'd have waited till the offseason to say this out loud.
 
mossy said:
What good is it for DOB to write that Upton will be moved while he's still here? I see this ending badly.

I'm no B. Upton fan, but I'd have waited till the offseason to say this out loud.
Click to expand...

It' can't really get much worse with Bossman. Come September I'd find a way to try out some guys in LF for the rotational OF
 
yeezus said:
I remember you said you'd take Jacob Turner over Minor.
Click to expand...

And your point is? It was immediately after the draft. The majority of the board (and most analysts) thought he was reach.

I also wanted to trade Beachy for Lorenzo Cain and was laughed at. Would be pretty nice to have Cain roaming CF right now wouldn't you say?
 
Carp said:
And your point is? It was immediately after the draft. The majority of the board (and most analysts) thought he was reach.

I also wanted to trade Beachy for Lorenzo Cain and was laughed at. Would be pretty nice to have Cain roaming CF right now wouldn't you say?
Click to expand...

We would have still signed BJ with Cain, he didn't do anything of any significance til last year. So who currrrrs.
 
No way that I'd dump BJ until I had resigned Justin. I'm sure Justin understands the business of baseball, etc, but I bet we'd save more resigning Justin with BJ still having a chance to play here than we would save in a BJ dump trade. That's and hoping BJ gets a Lasik, etc miracle this winter are really our only ways to minimizes our losses on this horrible contract. Or maybe BJ will get desperate and get on a good PED program!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top