Five Least Favorite Braves of All Time

striker42

Well-known member
Everyone knows who their favorite Braves of all time are. They know the players they loved watching. But which Braves players couldn't you stand? Who couldn't you wait to see leave the team? Here are my top 5.

5. Reggie Sanders- We gave up a lot to get this guy and he seemed to just be marking time. I never once got the feeling he enjoyed playing in Atlanta. About the only thing to improve during his time with the Braves was his skill at inspecting his bat walking back to the dugout after a strikeout.

4. Derek Lowe- He was given one of the largest contracts in Braves history and was terrible. He just about single handedly cost us a playoff appearance with his collapse. While I recognize that his decline was due to the unstoppable march of age and that it's not his fault that Wren was dumb enough to give him that contract, I still couldn't stand watching his fail and loudly blame everything but his declining ability. The DUI arrest didn't help matters.

3. Kenny Lofton- Unlike the others on this list, he actually didn't play poorly in his time in Atlanta getting on base at a .409 clip. That being said, I don't know if there was ever a worse fit than Lofton. The fact that Lofton couldn't play for Bobby Cox tells you something about him.

2. Melky Cabrera- Cabrera's hatred of playing in Atlanta was clear. He hated the fact the Yankees traded him and that he was no longer had the New York nightlife to enjoy. He let that affect his on the field performance. His play was so lackadaisical that he once caused an inside the park HR by throwing the ball sideways instead of towards the infield. I was happy the Braves didn't wait to non-tender him, instead releasing him after the season was over. Good riddance.

1. Hector Olivera- Between his lack of ability, sense of entitlement, and treatment of women, I can honestly say Olivera is my least favorite Brave of all time. To me, it's not even close. The only redeeming thing about his time in Atlanta was that it was brief, lasting only 108 PAs.
 
Btw the most horrific performance in the post-season I've ever seen from a Brave came from a player I liked quite a bit. So I won't name him.
 
Btw the most horrific performance in the post-season I've ever seen from a Brave came from a player I liked quite a bit. So I won't name him.

I'm not sure anyone's post season performance is worse than Melky in 2010. Late in the game (I think it was the elimination game), he hits a ground ball to the SS (I think it was Renteria). The SS boots the ball and you hear a cheer go up from the crowd only to die as soon as everyone looks over and sees Melky less than a third of the way to first. If he had been running hard he'd have easily beat the throw. He wasn't even jogging.
 
Hampton is in there for me. His contract killed us for many years.

Melky, HO are at the top for me. I will give honorable mention to AJ.. Even in 2015, he was such a determent to the rebuilding pitchers.

Fredi G. is also worth a mention. How he kept his job for so long kills me.

others.. KK, BJ
 
Vinny Castilla
B.J. Sureout
Melky Cabrera
Bret Frosted Tips Boone
Vinny Castilla

EDIT: To clarify, "B.J. Sureout" refers to Surhoff, not Upton. If Coppy tries to sign anyone with the initials B.J., fire him on the spot.
 
Attitude

Cabrera
Fick the Dick
Caddilac
Lofton
Marquis

Ability compared to what we should have received

Sureout
Sanders
D. Lowe
F-Uggla
BJ Upton
 
Who was that poor kid a few years ago who kept making errors against the Giants and Cox wouldn't pull him

Wasn't a big fan of Kolb, Boob Wickman, surhoff, Horacio Ramirez,

Rocker put some egg on the franchises face too

BJ Upton & Uggla

These guys may be decent human beings but sucked as MLB players
 
Fick really wasn't that bad until the NLDS dirty play. Unless I misremembered something else?

I also blame him (probably not rightfully) for us not getting David Ortiz. But as thewupk said, the NLDS play alone was enough.

Also, can't believe I forgot about Rocker.

It's easy to hate on Kotchman, but I blame JS and Bobby Cox for that one. Insisting we get a major league 1B back in return for Teixeira back us into a corner and forced us to go with Kotchman.
 
I also blame him (probably not rightfully) for us not getting David Ortiz. But as thewupk said, the NLDS play alone was enough.

Also, can't believe I forgot about Rocker.

It's easy to hate on Kotchman, but I blame JS and Bobby Cox for that one. Insisting we get a major league 1B back in return for Teixeira back us into a corner and forced us to go with Kotchman.

IIRC, Wren was the GM when we got Kotchman.
 
Back
Top