GDT 5/28/23: Braves vs Philthies - Putting it on the line

Hulavol said:
I concur on sitting Murph regularly- especially when Marcel is having the month he’s having.
Click to expand...

It's a good problem to find when you have too many bats that are producing to fit into the lineup. The problem is that we don't have the versatility to give other guys an occasional day off. For instance, we don't have anyone that can spell Riley or Olson for a day off their feet, even if it is just to DH for the day. I wouldn't mind seeing Harris getting a mental day off soon. Acuna could use a day off his feet and go in as DH.
 
Funny I literally don't have a single post complaining about other guys not being rested, albeit I do agree with others that Snit is horrendous at it. Case and point, no reason Acuna shouldn't get a single day off to continue to at least monitor over working him.

The Murphy one is different. We don't need to overwork him, the concern is that out of respect to TD, snit is playing Murphy like a part-time player as opposed to an all star. He is an elite player this year so it costs us valuable wins if he literally sits 1 out of every 3 games. Not suggesting he needs to play a 150 rate, but at least more than a 110 games played rate. Especially with the DH.
 
AJonesATL said:
Funny I literally don't have a single post complaining about other guys not being rested, albeit I do agree with others that Snit is horrendous at it. Case and point, no reason Acuna shouldn't get a single day off to continue to at least monitor over working him.

The Murphy one is different. We don't need to overwork him, the concern is that out of respect to TD, snit is playing Murphy like a part-time player as opposed to an all star. He is an elite player this year so it costs us valuable wins if he literally sits 1 out of every 3 games. Not suggesting he needs to play a 150 rate, but at least more than a 110 games played rate. Especially with the DH.
Click to expand...

Currently, Murph is the better hitter and the better defender, he should get a lions share of the games behind the dish. I think the reason TdA isn't getting a ton of DH appearances is a mixture of Ozunas hot bat and inability to play defense and no third catcher to guard against injury are main reasons.
 
Olson had a tremendous April (driven by an unsustainable BABIP and FB/HR) but there was a concern with his strikeout rate. While his overall numbers are down in May, his underlying metrics are improved across the board

April vs May
.252/.369/.563 vs .219/.350/.510
BABIP: .346 vs .213
K %: 35% vs 23%
Sw Strike %: 15.4% vs 13%
B% 14.8% vs 16.2%
EV: 95.2 vs 95.0

With how hard Olson hits the ball and plate discipline, keeping the k rate below 25% seems like the break even point for him to be a top 5 1B.
 
Last edited:
chop2chip said:
I’m actually in full support of resting Murphy frequently, especially with the production Ozuna gives us at DH and TDA being an above average catcher. I wish Snitker would make more efforts to rest our other star players.
Click to expand...

Yeah, i'm cool with resting Murphy. But do wish Snit would give Acuna, Olson, Riley, Albies more days off so they arent burnt out.
 
Hopefully we can pound Oakland into oblivion early in each game and let Charlie play first and third and Hilliard and Pilar cover the OF - ideally in the fourth inning each night.
Never happen, I know.
 
Hulavol said:
Hopefully we can pound Oakland into oblivion early in each game and let Charlie play first and third and Hilliard and Pilar cover the OF - ideally in the fourth inning each night.
Never happen, I know.
Click to expand...

I'm expecting to drop a game to them, baseball is stupid like that.
 
I suspect that the usage pattern for Murphy has been thoroughly discussed by Murphy and Snit, and Murphy has had some significant input. I believe that they are in agreement on the need for rest, and further, that when Ozuna cools off, as he will, that Murphy and d’Arnaud will both see significant AB’s at DH.

Snit is not beloved by the players because he makes unpopular decisions without their input.
 
The Braves' broadcast kept alluding to tough part of the schedule being done, but it's not quite over yet outside of the next 3 games.

Just in the next 12 days, the Braves will see:
Merrill Kelly
Zac Gallen
Max Scherzer
Justin Verlander
MacKenzie Gore

Atlanta needs to feast when they get to the Washington/Detroit/Colorado/Philadelphia/Cincinnati stretch
 
WaitingFor2017 said:
The Braves' broadcast kept alluding to tough part of the schedule being done, but it's not quite over yet outside of the next 3 games.

Just in the next 12 days, the Braves will see:
Merrill Kelly
Zac Gallen
Max Scherzer
Justin Verlander
MacKenzie Gore

Atlanta needs to feast when they get to the Washington/Detroit/Colorado/Philadelphia/Cincinnati stretch
Click to expand...

Arizona is a good team but the Mets and Nats aren't. Verlander and Scherzer aren't the aces they once were.
 
WaitingFor2017 said:
The Braves' broadcast kept alluding to tough part of the schedule being done, but it's not quite over yet outside of the next 3 games.

Just in the next 12 days, the Braves will see:
Merrill Kelly
Zac Gallen
Max Scherzer
Justin Verlander
MacKenzie Gore

Atlanta needs to feast when they get to the Washington/Detroit/Colorado/Philadelphia/Cincinnati stretch
Click to expand...
Dodgers, Orioles, Mets, Phillies, Mariners, and Rangers essentially back to back is brutal. Braves were lucky that they held their head above waters.

God bless Ozuna for leading the team
 
AJonesATL said:
Funny I literally don't have a single post complaining about other guys not being rested, albeit I do agree with others that Snit is horrendous at it. Case and point, no reason Acuna shouldn't get a single day off to continue to at least monitor over working him.

The Murphy one is different. We don't need to overwork him, the concern is that out of respect to TD, snit is playing Murphy like a part-time player as opposed to an all star. He is an elite player this year so it costs us valuable wins if he literally sits 1 out of every 3 games. Not suggesting he needs to play a 150 rate, but at least more than a 110 games played rate. Especially with the DH.
Click to expand...

Well he’s catching tonight so there you go
 
If TDA is being used in an ideal fashion he's platooning with Rosario. Let Murphy DH and put Ozuna in LF. Gets everyone plenty of usage and rest.
 
I will no longer question the way the Braves handle the catcher position. They have proven beyond all doubt they know exactly how to get value behind the plate.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top