GDT 9/2/19: Happy Labor Day!!!

msstate7 said:
Who was it that used to mock me for comparing Soto and Acuna?

Acuna 4.8 fWAR
Soto 4.6 fWAR

Offensively, Soto is clearly superior, so far
Click to expand...

that’s not how i remember it.
i remember you complaining last season in just about every thread that Soto was the stud Acuña was supposed to be.
of course that quieted when Acuña started getting hot and overtook Soto. it was also pointed out by many that Acuña is the better overall player.
you’re also now catching Acuña on a cold streak (he was at 5.1 WAR not that long ago) and Soto on a hot streak.
so short answer: no one. no one mocked you for comparing them. you were mocked, however, for the level of whining we saw when Soto was hot and Acuña was cold.
 
Super said:
that’s not how i remember it.
i remember you complaining last season in just about every thread that Soto was the stud Acuña was supposed to be.
of course that quieted when Acuña started getting hot and overtook Soto. it was also pointed out by many that Acuña is the better overall player.
you’re also now catching Acuña on a cold streak (he was at 5.1 WAR not that long ago) and Soto on a hot streak.
so short answer: no one. no one mocked you for comparing them. you were mocked, however, for the level of whining we saw when Soto was hot and Acuña was cold.
Click to expand...

Kinda like you brought this up when Soto had his cold streak to begin the year, eh?

ETA... they're pretty much equal.

Career fWAR:
Acuna (248 games) - 8.5 (.034 per game)
Soto (240 games) - 8.3 (.035 per game)
 
Last edited:
O'Day has 6 K's now in 4 scoreless innings on his rehab. He had 2 more K's today in one scoreless inning for the G-Braves.
 
Enscheff said:
Culberson has been the luckiest Braves hitter the last 2 years in limited exposure. That luck has run out and Culberson is looking more like the ~.270 xwOBA true talent guy he actually is.

Culberson doesn’t “need” anything other than being used as the player he actually is: a versatile bench player that isn’t very good offensively. He’s basically Hech with less SS ability and more OF ability.
Click to expand...

Do you think it’s possible Culberson doesn’t make the postseason roster then?
 
msstate7 said:
Kinda like you brought this up when Soto had his cold streak to begin the year, eh?

ETA... they're pretty much equal.

Career fWAR:
Acuna (248 games) - 8.5 (.034 per game)
Soto (240 games) - 8.3 (.035 per game)
Click to expand...

lol you bent the truth to make yourself feel like a victim and right. but that’s not what happened. you complained incessantly. you don’t remember that?
Acuña is still the better overall player. i’m not sure what your point is. i’ll take acuña long-term. you can take soto. ok.
 
Slippyjms said:
Do you think it’s possible Culberson doesn’t make the postseason roster then?
Click to expand...

Possible. I think we will take only one of Culberson, Hech and Camargo.

We will likely go to a 12 man staff and therefore have room for an extra bat. My guess is the playoff bench looks like this:

1) Cervelli
2) Flowers
3) Hamilton
4) Joyce
5) one of Culberson, Hech, Camargo

This assumes Muk and Ender return and are on the post-season roster. I think we go with 3 catchers to allow us to pinch run with Hamilton more aggressively. It would also allow us to use the catchers as pinch hitters.
 
nsacpi said:
Possible. I think we will take only one of Culberson, Hech and Camargo.

We will likely go to a 12 man staff and therefore have room for an extra bat. My guess is the playoff bench looks like this:

1) Cervelli
2) Flowers
3) Hamilton
4) Joyce
5) one of Culberson, Hech, Camargo

This assumes Muk and Ender return and are on the post-season roster. I think we go with 3 catchers to allow us to pinch run with Hamilton more aggressively. It would also allow us to use the catchers as pinch hitters.
Click to expand...

Joyce should be starting vs righties. Also, if we beat our first round opponent then against the Dodgers lefties we cannot go with Muk and Ender and expect to win, healthy or not. We'll need someone like Duvall for Muk/Joyce against Ryu for example.
 
Braves1976 said:
Joyce should be starting vs righties. Also, if we beat our first round opponent then against the Dodgers lefties we cannot go with Muk and Ender and expect to win, healthy or not. We'll need someone like Duvall for Muk/Joyce against Ryu for example.
Click to expand...

What's the latest on ender and markakis return dates?
 
Braves1976 said:
Joyce should be starting vs righties. Also, if we beat our first round opponent then against the Dodgers lefties we cannot go with Muk and Ender and expect to win, healthy or not. We'll need someone like Duvall for Muk/Joyce against Ryu for example.
Click to expand...

For his career Ryu has given up an OPS of .714 against lefties and .666 against righties.

This year his splits are conventional. But the larger sample is a better predictor of future performance for splits. He is a reverse splits pitcher. Partly because of his changeup and ability to pitch down and away against righties. He has a classic profile for a reverse splits pitcher. His best pitch is his change. You negate that with lefty hitters. Hopefully, the Braves will figure that out.
 
Last edited:
msstate7 said:
What's the latest on ender and markakis return dates?
Click to expand...

Ender is jogging and Muk has started playing catch. Still a couple weeks away. They will probably be able to play the last 5-10 games of the season. Cutting it close as far as fully regaining game sharpness.
 
nsacpi said:
For his career Ryu has given up an OPS of .714 against lefties and .666 against righties.

This year his splits are conventional. But the larger sample is a better predictor of future performance for splits. He is a reverse splits pitcher. Partly because of his changeup and ability to pitch down and away against righties. He has a classic profile for a reverse splits pitcher. His best pitch is his change. You negate that with lefty hitters. Hopefully, the Braves will figure that out.
Click to expand...

You said the same last time but it was our righties that hit him best and that has been a trend against him lately in his struggles.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top