Agreed. Plus he brings a lot of power on offense, trading away what we need more of (offense) isn't the answer.
I'm more for trading CB. It's risky but trading from our Cs is the only way to improve our team via trade or get someone to take Bossman that doesn't eman giving up one of your young pitchers.
I've mused over what I'd try to do to make the team better and this is what I came up with.
Bossman, Graham, and CB for Dickey and Buehrle with some cash swapping where we get money in 2015 and give that back to Toronto in 2016. Toronto is making a gamble basically, they will almost certainly be improving at catcher, while taking a gamble in CF. Rasmus is a FA and Gose is not off to a great start If they think they can fix Bossman they could seriously improve their position player standing, like the Braves the Jays have a ton of pitching propsects, so losing Buehrle for a season will sting, but they should be able to soften the blow. On the money side, DIckey and Buehrle are owed a staggering 31M so they kick some cash our way and we'd repay them plus a little the following few years. ON our end Buehrle is solid as a rock. Year in and year out he's basically the same pitcher, ERA in mid-high 3s, Hip in high 3s/low 4s and xFIP in low to mid4s. and 200+ innings. He should be a 3 WAR or so pitcher. And we can only hope either returning to the NL or McDOwell can turn Dickey around. If he can get back to his mid 3 FIP ways we'll be pretty set in the rotation.
I'd offer Medlen and Beachy 1 year incentive laden deals based on IP. I'd do the same with Floyd. I expect Floyd to turn it down given our glut of pitching.
I would trade Chris Johnson to the highest bidder and sign Chris Johnson. I would pur Peraza in CF starting tomorrow. I have my concerns about him but considering we've gotten nothing from CF offensively the last few years he can't be worse. Free Agent CG market is bare. Though I'll add if Jason doesn't sign an extension, then I'd just move him to CF and sign Cruz or Morse if we can make it work monetarily.
Anyway I'm being optimistic and saying Jason stays.
RF - Jason
LF - Justin
1B - Freeman
C - Gattis
3B - Headley
2B - TLS
SS - Simmons
P
CF - Peraza
Peraza has the speed but I doubt he can hit enough now to be a 1 or 2, instead treat him as a false leadoff man. When he gets on it's like he's leading off.
Bench
FA C (Honestly pretty much all backup catchers are equals, I'd rank my top 3 in order, Ross, Buck, Laird)
Pena
Gosselin
Cunningham
Terds.
Rotation
Buehrle
Julio
Minor
Dickey
Wood
Yes I'm splitting up lefties, yes I know that's largely unnecessary. Just playing it like every mlb manager would.
Pen
Kimbel
Walden
Medlen (assuming health all around)
Beachy (ditto)
Carpenter
Russell
Varvaro
I know, no lefties, but Medlen to me is the lefty killer. He should be able to work his excellent change. And of course the odds of Medlen and Beachy being on the team and healthy are super low then Avilan comes into play or maybe a FA like Andrew Miller
