Markakis and Castro are basically a wash value wise. Castro is younger and has upside, but Nick is clearly the better player right now. So basically the gut of the trade would be Teheran for Baez which is underwhelming to say the least. But if they added Contreras to the deal, I'd have to consider it.
Miller market 'hot'
- Thread starter Hawk
- Start date
Markakis and Castro are basically a wash value wise. Castro is younger and has upside, but Nick is clearly the better player right now. So basically the gut of the trade would be Teheran for Baez which is underwhelming to say the least. But if they added Contreras to the deal, I'd have to consider it.
NinersSBChamps
<B>Voted Worst Poster <br> 2015 (Co-Winner)</BR>20
Just don't see how we can rationalize trading a great pitcher away for some maybe prospects. Miller is a stud. He can anchor a pitching staff moving forward.
He has a better K rate and FIP. Other than that, he does not have better numbers than Miller or Julio. He's been an ace for exactly 1 half of a season in 2014. This year he was good, not great. He was not better Miller in 2015 and he wasn't better than Julio in 2014. Not to mention Julio and Miller have proven significantly more durable.
I'd punch the Johns senseless if they traded Freeman for that.
Gammons pretty much said the same thing on MLB Tonight. He did say that he thinks it probably gets done as Soler plus for him.
NinersSBChamps
<B>Voted Worst Poster <br> 2015 (Co-Winner)</BR>20
And who could be the plus?
cajunrevenge
Well-known member
Gammon stopped being a credible source for anything other than Red Sox news a long time ago. He just reports hid own speculation.
zitothebrave
Connoisseur of Minors
Billy McKinney hopefully. Really go bonkers on corner OF bats.
Only issue with the Soler for Miller is the Markakis and Olivera in the room. Obviously we could put Olivera at 3B and pray but that's all we'd be doing is praying. Considering we are looking at him in LF right now that means we can't get Soler without trading Markakis. Or we have to trade Freddie and move someone to 1B.
bravesfanMatt
Steve Harvey'd
maybe trade HO/Freeman and Markickass...
I would do Miller/Markakis for Soler/McKinney. And if we could find a way to add more and also pull Contreras that would be phenomenal. I seriously doubt the Cubs want to give up that much for any package, but I'd push for it.
striker42
Well-known member
I'm inclined to move Olivera back to third and get Soler. I don't see Olivera's bat playing well in left. We pretty much have to have him hit best case scenario for him to be worth his paycheck there. At third we have a little more room for error.
I doubt he'll ever be a good defensive third baseman but maybe he could be a mediocre one.
bravesfanMatt
Steve Harvey'd
I think the cubs would want Markickass in this deal and we would want to include him. Just not sure about getting McKinney since the cubs are already giving up one outfield prospect. Maybe get Contreras/Soler/Salary dump for Miller/Markickass.. I do think Nick at night fits perfect into the Cubs offense..
I said this without really thinking. It would probably have to be something along the lines of Miller/Folty/Markakis, at least, to pull Soler/McKinney. And then more to add Contreras. I'd still be open to it, though.
Heyward
<B>Voted Worst Poster <br>'13, '14, '15 (Co-Winner
Who is Markickass (laughing)
zitothebrave
Connoisseur of Minors
Major league average 3B last year was a .319 wOBA and LF was .317 those numbers largely are the same the last few years. Pretty close to each other. 3B is an offensive position first as is LF. If he can handle LF better than 3B, then he should be out there. He's gonna be on this team for a few years might as well milk every ounce of value out of him.
bravesfanMatt
Steve Harvey'd
that is how I will refer to him when speaking of him being traded. I think he is Kickass.. but not right for the Braves.. Now no one will confuse me with thinking he stinks..
Hudson2
Well-known member
If we get more than Soler I'd want Underwood or Contreras back. Contreras would set us up at catcher for a long time. And Underwood is a SP prospect with a ton of potential. The Johns probably want a pitcher back but Soler and Underwood would be awesome. If we added Markakis I'd try to get Soler, Underwood, and Contreras somehow.
I think a deal based around Miller/Markakis for Soler/Castro might be something to consider.
Castro could play SS and make Aybar trade bait, or he could play 2B. He is still young and could improve.
The Cubs could sign Heyward and play him In CF with Schwarber and Markakis at the corners. Baez would play 2B.
Some money or other minor parts might have to go either way, but the 4 headline players makes at least some sense.
Castro could play SS and make Aybar trade bait, or he could play 2B. He is still young and could improve.
The Cubs could sign Heyward and play him In CF with Schwarber and Markakis at the corners. Baez would play 2B.
Some money or other minor parts might have to go either way, but the 4 headline players makes at least some sense.
Hudson2
Well-known member
I'd rather make it Soler and Contreras and keep Markakis. Sign Zobrist and we could compete next year and keep all of our prostpects. This lineup would be very competitive.
Cf - Mallex
2b - Zobrist
1b - Freeman
Lf - Soler
RF - Markakis
3b - Olivera
SS - Aybar
C - Contreras
We'd have money left to sign sombody like Fister on a one year deal and get another good bullpen piece.
Cf - Mallex
2b - Zobrist
1b - Freeman
Lf - Soler
RF - Markakis
3b - Olivera
SS - Aybar
C - Contreras
We'd have money left to sign sombody like Fister on a one year deal and get another good bullpen piece.
bravesfanMatt
Steve Harvey'd
who are you trading to get Soler/Contreras? and they both would be on our 40 man.. so we would have to ship/release/whatever CB.. that leaves one spot left... you have Zobrist/bp piece/ and Fister... So two would have to go.. who??
bravesfanMatt
Steve Harvey'd
that is my thought.. the cubs would love a guy like Nick Markickass.. the fans would moan and groan.. but he would be a very good fit for that team.. and like you said.. Heyward in center would make their outfield very good. plus a starting 3 of Jake/John/Shelby is pretty good with that offense..I would make them favorites in the NL..