My number 1 is Sandy Alderson. I think what he's done with the Mets in terms of player development, the trade market, and team relations is textbook worthy.
As for Rizzo (although I will admit, he is definitely no Jim Bowden,) the main issue is my perception of his personality. For example: firing Rick Eckstein recently without even talking to Davey Johnson ahead of time. Also, I think the signings of Werth and Soriano were ill-advised. At the time I remember a lot of pundits saying that Werth was a high-priced signal to players (and the league) that the Nationals were around to spend and win. Still, they owe him $60MM from now until his age 38 season (2017.) And, with the exception of this season, he hasn't produced for them at all except in his role as Harper's 'mentor' and handler. I guess the Soriano signing bothers me the most -- mainly because he ousted a young, viable, and cheap option from closers role with little delicacy in the process, but also because Rizzo treated it as an icing on the cake move, "strengthening a strength," when it actually caused strife in the bullpen to the point where Tyler Clippard called out management (Rizzo) about a month ago for their handling of the Storen situation.
And then there's this:
"Cole Hamels says he's old school? He's the polar opposite of old school. He's fake tough," Rizzo said, according to the report. "He thinks he's going to intimidate us after hitting our 19-year-old rookie who's eight games into the big leagues? He doesn't know who he's dealing with.
"He thinks he's sending a message to us of being a tough guy. He's sending the polar opposite message. He says he's being honest, well, I'm being honest. It was a gutless chicken (bleep-bleeping) act," Rizzo added, according to the report. "That was a fake-tough act. No one has ever accused Cole Hamels of being old school."
"This goes beyond rivalry and all that stuff," Rizzo added. "This points to, you take the youngest guy in baseball. He's never done a thing. And then Hamels patted himself on the back. Harper's old school. Hitting him on the back, that ain't old school. That's (bleeping) chicken (bleep)."