Official 2024 Off-Season Thread!

bravesfanMatt said:
I am just glad the braves got someone. Not going to really panic that a part time player might be slightly worse than player Y. I am way more concerned on managing of said player than if this weak side platoon is marginally worse.
Click to expand...

I'm more concerned with the 15 decisions that were made before a panic buy of Duvall occurred. It was not a mystery the Braves needed a legit 4th OFer to protect against the risk in the OF.

Anyone caught off guard by the idea Kelenic may flop, or Acuna's knee is a risk should be...talked to sternly.
 
Enscheff said:
Oh wow, guys....we just learned Kelenic may not be good and Acuna may have future knee issues after major surgery!

We didn't know this 3 weeks ago when the superior 4th OFer signed for $2M, so we better run out and panic buy the lesser 4th OFer for $3M!!

Good job guys! That was a tricky lesson to learn, even though forum posters understood it months ago!

Whew...now that we learned so much and did such a great job, let's head to the Waffle House to celebrate!!
Click to expand...

It's entirely possible we simply didn't want Grichuk, no matter the price. Or it's entirely possible Grichuk didn't want to play here. It's also entirely possible we really like Duvie but were comfortable with the team we had to not spend the 5-10 million he was likely asking for earlier in the off-season. But when his price tag dropped, we thought he was too good a value to pass up.

Also, I am not sure how or why you think Grichuk is a better player than Duvie.
 
Last edited:
I’m guessing that familiarity played a big roll in Duval also. They know him pretty well and like him. I think Duval is just insurance in case Acuna needs a few days off here or there and Kelenic plays like crap.
 
Carp said:
It's entirely possible we simply didn't want Grichuk, no matter the price. Or it's entirely possible Grichuk didn't want to play here. It's also entirely possible we really like Duvie but were comfortable with the team we had to not spend the 5-10 million he was likely asking for earlier in the off-season. But when his price tag dropped, we thought he was too good a value to pass up.

Also, I am not sure how or why you think Grichuk is a better player than Duvie.
Click to expand...

Well, I literally posted the stats that show Gruchuk is a much better hitter vs LHP than Duvall, which is literally the role they both fill on their respective roster. So I guess it's up to you to decide if those stats show what everyone around the sport agrees they show.

If not, maybe you have come up with other stats to prove who is better vs LHP?
 
Hudson2 said:
I’m guessing that familiarity played a big roll in Duval also. They know him pretty well and like him. I think Duval is just insurance in case Acuna needs a few days off here or there and Kelenic plays like crap.
Click to expand...

I'm guessing that Duvall will hit a HR late in a game and will become the starter with the $26M Kelenic pushed to the bench...wasting all chances of him progressing to what everyone hopes he can become.

But this is a good point. If Duvall is more Acuna insurance than Kelenic platoon partner, it makes sense to go with the better all around hitter...which is definitely Duvall. But again...Acuna's knee was always a risk...it should not be a new revelation.
 
Last edited:
Enscheff said:
I'm guessing that Duvall will hit a HR late in a game and will become the starter with the $26M Kelenic pushed to the bench...wasting all chances of him progressing to what everyone hopes he can become.

But this is a good point. If Duvall is more Acuna insurance than Kelenic platoon partner, it makes sense to go with the better all around hitter...which is definitely Duvall. But again...Acuna's knee was always a risk...it should not be a new revelation.
Click to expand...

Or it could be that Duvall was looking for $5 million plus earlier in the off season and the Braves probably had this offer on the table for months… when he realized he wasn’t going to get what he wanted, maybe he went back to the Braves and said, “that deal still on the table?”

The thing is, we don’t really know how it all went down and I think you’re getting weirdly emotional about this move and just relying on a ton of assumptions
 
Enscheff said:
Well, I literally posted the stats that show Gruchuk is a much better hitter vs LHP than Duvall, which is literally the role they both fill on their respective roster. So I guess it's up to you to decide if those stats show what everyone around the sport agrees they show.

If not, maybe you have come up with other stats to prove who is better vs LHP?
Click to expand...

Then I guess the next question is, how much playing time are you expecting for each guy? Because Grichuk is unplayable vs RHP, which represents ~75% of the pitchers in baseball. Duvall represents a better all around player, and in the event someone gets injured, he is an acceptable starter.
 
zbhargrove said:
Or it could be that Duvall was looking for $5 million plus earlier in the off season and the Braves probably had this offer on the table for months… when he realized he wasn’t going to get what he wanted, maybe he went back to the Braves and said, “that deal still on the table?”

The thing is, we don’t really know how it all went down and I think you’re getting weirdly emotional about this move and just relying on a ton of assumptions
Click to expand...

Exactly. Overreacting to signing Duvall is a new level of weird.
 
Carp said:
Exactly. Overreacting to signing Duvall is a new level of weird.
Click to expand...

Very.

Braves filled a need for a 4th OF and the conclusion is that the best GM in baseball didn’t foresee Kelenic being bad or Acuna getting hurt, but message posters knew this months ago lol.

It’s fine to evaluate the decision to sign Duvall the player. It’s silly to posture the reason why he was signed.
 
chop2chip said:
Very.

Braves filled a need for a 4th OF and the conclusion is that the best GM in baseball didn’t foresee Kelenic being bad or Acuna getting hurt, but message posters knew this months ago lol.

It’s fine to evaluate the decision to sign Duvall the player. It’s silly to posture the reason why he was signed.
Click to expand...

Yup - Its jsut more of the same.....
 
Carp said:
Then I guess the next question is, how much playing time are you expecting for each guy? Because Grichuk is unplayable vs RHP, which represents ~75% of the pitchers in baseball. Duvall represents a better all around player, and in the event someone gets injured, he is an acceptable starter.
Click to expand...

Indeed. So if the Braves went from, "we don't have any PAs to give a 4th OFer", to, "uh oh, we better have a potential everyday guy on the bench", over the course of 3 weeks during ST...what changed?

They just realized Kelenic may not be good? They just realized Acuna's knee is a risk? These things weren't known months ago?

Maybe it was as simple as Duvall's asking price finally dropping enough to fit in the budget as a bench piece, or a combination of all 3.
 
Enscheff said:
Indeed. So if the Braves went from, "we don't have any PAs to give a 4th OFer", to, "uh oh, we better have a potential everyday guy on the bench", over the course of 3 weeks during ST...what changed?

They just realized Kelenic may not be good? They just realized Acuna's knee is a risk? These things weren't known months ago?

Maybe it was as simple as Duvall's asking price finally dropping enough to fit in the budget as a bench piece, or a combination of all 3.
Click to expand...

It seems pretty obvious the budget dictated a lot of this. We are/were around 7ish million below the next tax threshold. We also know that AA likes to leave enough money in the budget to make mid-season trades when necessary. This would suggest we weren't looking to add anyone for more than 2-3 million that Duvall eventually signed for. Acuna's injury scare could have played a part in this, but it seems more likely that we were being a bit frugal with the remaining budget.

And reports in January were that the Red Sox and the Angels were supposedly in a "bidding war" for Duvall's services. Now it seems that both teams moved on and he overplayed his market.
 
Last edited:
I mean Duvall can’t be too upset. He is getting 3 million to watch a great team play every night. Tuck twit in every game for his nap. And flail away for about 100 plate appearances when twit forgets to turn in the permanent marker lineup.
 
Carp said:
It's entirely possible we simply didn't want Grichuk, no matter the price. Or it's entirely possible Grichuk didn't want to play here. It's also entirely possible we really like Duvie but were comfortable with the team we had to not spend the 5-10 million he was likely asking for earlier in the off-season. But when his price tag dropped, we thought he was too good a value to pass up.

Also, I am not sure how or why you think Grichuk is a better player than Duvie.
Click to expand...

I think we as a fan base need to finally come to terms with that not every player wants to play in Atlanta. Swanson clearly didn't even if it was his "hometown" team. I think we are about to learn Max feels the same.
 
Enscheff said:
Indeed. So if the Braves went from, "we don't have any PAs to give a 4th OFer", to, "uh oh, we better have a potential everyday guy on the bench", over the course of 3 weeks during ST...what changed?

They just realized Kelenic may not be good? They just realized Acuna's knee is a risk? These things weren't known months ago?

Maybe it was as simple as Duvall's asking price finally dropping enough to fit in the budget as a bench piece, or a combination of all 3.
Click to expand...

I think your big mistake here is taking anything the Braves or front office is saying in public without a massive grain of salt
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top