Maybin is bad, but not Eric Young level bad.
Though, boom Young has a .500 slugging percentage in 2015.
*OPENING DAY* 4/6/'15: Atlanta Braves (Teheran) @ Miami Marlins
- Thread starter The Tariff King
- Start date
Maybin is bad, but not Eric Young level bad.
Though, boom Young has a .500 slugging percentage in 2015.
Tapate50
Well-known member
I am not sure you have seen who we are trotting out there in the OF. He isn't much, but we don't have much.
Julio3000
<B>A Chip Off the Old Rock</B>
^ that ^
Eric Young doesn't trot.
Tapate50
Well-known member
I need someone to photoshop a horse trotting on Huddy's ankle, stat.
Tapate50
Well-known member
I mean, half of camp we still expected a guy that never showed up to win a spot on the 25 man!
I'm just saying there's no need for anyone to get all butt hurt about Maybin playing or not. Some people here are acting like we have this guy with huge potential being blocked by EY. None of these guys are any good or have much potential at this point. We probably go into extra innings yesterday because there's no way anyone gets by that throw from 2nd base other than EY.
Tapate50
Well-known member
I don't think anyone is butt hurt. I think the general consensus is he isn't very good. That said, it wouldn't hurt to find out if it was injuries or Petco that MAY (emphasis on MAY) have diminished his output. If not, no big deal and Eric Young can go a trottin' on out there. The downside is...well there isn't much of one because he isn't taking meaningful AB's from ANYONE on this roster.
Julio3000
<B>A Chip Off the Old Rock</B>
EY shouldn't be in a position to block anyone who is better—who is potentially better—than EY. Eury Perez may be better. Todd Cunningham may be better. Maybin is better. Even if he's not a prospect anymore, he's been an injury-prone guy who still may have some upside. He's signed for next year, too, so unless we plan to DFA him, it would be useful to play him to see if he can rebuild any value.
Like MFII said in another thread—information is more valuable to us this season than the odd win here and there. EY has 1500 MLB PAs. He's not going to put up a decent offensive season outside of Coors Field, and he's not a good defender in CF. He is a 1-tool player.
We probably go into extra innings yesterday because there's no way anyone gets by that throw from 2nd base other than EY.
Well, you can play that game all day. If Todd Cunningham were starting yesterday, he might have hit a HR.
We might as well turn it around on Markakis, Kelly Johnson, Chris Johnson, Alberto Callaspo and the rest of these guys not named Freeman or Simmons. We can play that same game with the rest of the roster too. Cameron Maybin and EY are both bad baseball players. It really doesn't matter who plays. The information on Maybin has been out for a while, he's a bust. Young had a good spring as well and could end up batting .300 and get himself traded at the deadline as well.
That throw from 2nd is an out at the plate almost every time. Saying no one else would have scored when the fastest guy on the team beat the throw by a split second is a hell of a lot different than throwing out a hypothetical Cunningham HR. Todd Cunningham didn't hit a home run. EY actually played and scored the game winning run.
Fans can sense the excitement.
Dalyn
Fredi Gonzalez Supporter
I think all these major changes draw the curious, but only winning will keep the majority of them watching. Has very little, if anything, to do with support.
I am butthurt about Maybin not playing.
We're not paying Eric Young $24MM guaranteed over the course of the next three years.
Seeing whether or not Maybin can produce is much more imperative than trying to ascertain whether or not EY is a better player (hint: he isn't).
BTW, I should add: I like Eric Young a lot -- his brand of baseball, his skillset, etc., so I hope he is given a lot of playing time on the corners.
We're not paying Eric Young $24MM guaranteed over the course of the next three years.
Seeing whether or not Maybin can produce is much more imperative than trying to ascertain whether or not EY is a better player (hint: he isn't).
BTW, I should add: I like Eric Young a lot -- his brand of baseball, his skillset, etc., so I hope he is given a lot of playing time on the corners.
Dalyn
Fredi Gonzalez Supporter
BUT HE HAD A DOUBLE.
Agreed.
and he;s the only one that could have scored that run.
The Bethancourt batting 5th thing is real, apparently.
Dalyn
Fredi Gonzalez Supporter
I was surprised as **** that he made it in there.