Second ('Third') Trump Presidency Thread

Don’t worry - we are keeping the top 1000
First, it is stupid to think you can identify such people ahead of time. Being in the top 1000, whatever that means, involves a lot of luck in addition to talent.

Second, much of the benefit of immigration comes from how the special combination of immigrant grit and American opportunity creates a special synergy in the next generation.

Third, most of the contribution to the country, the overwhelming majority of the contribution, comes not from the top 1000, but from the 50 million others. Plus eventually their children who across every generation and every ethnic group have shown extraordinary upward mobility.

It is a shame you and so many others are willing to overlook the facts and the analysis and choosing to advocate for policies that will greatly harm Americans.
 
First, it is stupid to think you can identify such people.

Second, much of the benefit of immigration is how the special combination of immigrant grit and American opportunity creates a special synergy in the next generation.

Third, most of the contribution from the country, the overwhelming majority of the contribution, comes not from the top 1000, but from the 50 million others. Plus eventually their children who across every generation and every ethnic group have shown extraordinary upward mobility.

It is a shame you and so many others are willing to overlook the facts and the analysis and choosing to advocate for policies that will greatly harm Americans.
I’m aware of your studies. We are unmoved by obvious lies. Strip away the top 1000 which are actually easy to identify and it’s a net negative. So we will continue to deport until the hirde is trimmed substantially and then more carefully curate future immigrants that not only contribute but are compatible with western society.
 
if it is so easy please provide your list of people who are in line to become the next top 1000

i'll settle for one or two names

Easy - take every SVP and above at Fortune 500 companies. This is mostly publicly available.
Take all phd professors (I still respect it)

Then private business owners who ar immigrants with 10m or more in revenues.

So easy to trim a list to people who represent the majority of your immigrants contributions
 
I’m not even saying deport the rest. I just laugh at your studies that are heavily dependent on the top 10/100/1000/10000 people to present a case that large scale immigration is good for host nation.
 
Easy - take every SVP and above at Fortune 500 companies. This is mostly publicly available.
Take all phd professors (I still respect it)

Then private business owners who ar immigrants with 10m or more in revenues.

So easy to trim a list to people who represent the majority of your immigrants contributions
eh...few were SVP's or PhDs when they immigrated
 
eh...few were SVP's or PhDs when they immigrated
And those same people that made their way through would have an opportunity to demonstrate their value and compatibility with our country when we have a strict merit based system that ignores whole countries.
 
You say that but are against methods to confirm that. And that is what Trump will be doing.

We heard the same song and dance with GA before.
THOSE METHODS DO NOT CONFIRM IT.

A non-american citizen can get a real ID. Voter rolls exist for a reason. Again, I don't care if Voter ID is a law, but the government HAS to provide it for free and minimal boundaries.
 
THOSE METHODS DO NOT CONFIRM IT.

A non-american citizen can get a real ID. Voter rolls exist for a reason. Again, I don't care if Voter ID is a law, but the government HAS to provide it for free and minimal boundaries.

I don’t think the government should charge people. But your “minimal” boundaries include making someone go down to a public office to get one.

And a real voter ID does confirm it because states are issuing IDs to illegals in droves. The voter rolls are aged. Mail in ballots are sent to all voters and no chain of custody upon the vote. You don’t care about any of that though
 
Back
Top